The Europeanization of Nordic Gender Equality: A Foucauldian Analysis of Reconciling Work and Family in Finland

Abstract

In this article, we analyse the case of reconciling work and family as a particularly illuminative example of the effects of soft Europeanization. We focus on one particular policy instrument of the EU, namely projects co‐funded by the European Social Fund (ESF), which have sought to develop family‐friendly arrangements in Finnish workplaces. Our analysis suggests that this soft law instrument can result in significant changes in member states, even in cases where the member state's own policy is well entrenched. Theoretically, our contribution is to connect soft Europeanization to the Foucauldian theory on power, and the literature on Analytics of Government specifically. From this perspective we argue that the ESF development projects function as Foucauldian ‘technologies of involvement’. We find that by stabilizing and normalizing project techniques and managerial rationalities untypical for previous gender equality and work–family policies in the country, the ESF projects in our case partly challenge some established principles of Nordic welfare policies, such as universalism and state responsibility for welfare measures. Moreover, as ESF projects have managed to involve mainly female‐dominated organizations and women as participants, we pose the question whether this kind of soft‐law instrument that trusts the self‐regulation capacities of actors can bring about change in gendered conventions.

Wind from the North, don’t go forth? Gender equality and the rise of populist nationalism in Finland

“…For instance, ‘Europe’ has also played an important role, with a general turn away from rights-based strategies towards arguments about gender equality assisting in economic growth (Elomäki, 2015; Rönnblom, 2009), highlighting the susceptibility of mainstreaming to economic discourses that depoliticise the struggle for a more gender-equal society (Rönnblom, 2011). European trends have also been influential in Finland (Eräranta, 2011; Eräranta and Kantola, 2016) and efficiency arguments about women’s employment appeal to NCP more than gender equality as such (Kokoomus, 2015). In the Finnish context, where women’s work attachment is already relatively strong, a limited conception of equality obscures the structural pitfalls of existing arrangements for diverse groups of women (e.g.…”

European Integration and Disintegration: Feminist Perspectives on Inequalities and Social Justice

“…An approach to integration based on the Foucauldian idea of governmentality addresses ‘how gendered norms and rationalities of government are discursively constructed through policies and politics and how these in turn are influenced by mostly essentialist gender norms and assumptions’ (Wöhl, , p. 239). Governmentality approaches stress the ambivalent effects of EU's political and economic power, which can be both repressive and enabling or empowering (Wöhl, , p. 239; Eräranta and Kantola, ).…”

Inter-Agency Analysis of EU Specialised Administrative Services: Insights from the Republic of Cyprus

“…The inconsistency between EU policies and rules and the internal institutional structures (goodness-of-fit) triggers pressure for change (Knill et al, 2009). On the other hand, soft Europeanisation focuses its attention to the role of ideas and actors in the procedure of change or resistance and to their expected and unintended outcomes (Eräranta and Kantola, 2016). Soft Europeanisation underlines the role of informal institutions in changing policy, as well as resisting change.…”