The heterogeneity of Chinese consumer values: a dual structure explanation

Abstract

Purpose -This paper aims to discuss inconsistent and often contradictory consumer values and consumption behaviours in contemporary China. The seemingly paradox is explained by the dual structure theory of consumer value system. Design/methodology/approach -This study provides a comprehensive overview and an in-depth analysis of Chinese cultural values from a theoretical perspective. Findings -Although the Chinese value system may appear coherent relative to those of other societies, it contains inconsistent elements that are the seeds of conflict, confusion, and change. Those contradictory values have coexisted and interacted with each other from a historical perspective. Research limitations/implications -Although the argument raised in this paper has support from prior literature and anecdotal observations, it should undergo further empirical validation. Practical implications -Given that consumption values vary across different consumer segments, different strategies should be developed for each segment. Those Western businesses who capitalize on these inherent contradictory, heterogeneous value elements will have the advantage over those who do not. Originality/value -This work challenges the conventional view that the Chinese have preserved homogeneous values, and provides a case in which there is a danger in using the nation-state as a surrogate for culture and as a unit of analysis.

Chinese import demand for wine: evidence from econometric estimations

“…New consumers are searching for differentiation, brand and origin reputation, luxury goods and status symbols, and they participate in conspicuous consumption. These trends derive from the Chinese social evolution highlighted by several scholars (Bi et al, 2012;Li et al, 2009;Lin & Wang, 2010;Taylor, 2014;Wang et al, 2013;Zhao & Belk, 2007).…”

“…significant differences between individuals living in rural areas and in urban areas; the former are linked to traditional consumption patterns, and the latter towards achievement and modernity, which leads to the consumption of foreign products (Lin & Wang, 2010) and . members of the one-child generation, who are less inclined to save and more prone to break with communist values than previous generations (Lin & Wang, 2010).…”

Not a simple coffee shop: local, global and glocal dimensions of the consumption of Starbucks in China

“…How the added expense of foreign brands and the risks of the marketplace are understood and negotiated -and how resulting choices are legitimated or not -will reflect the cultural habitus of Chinese consumers (Bourdieu, 1984). Cultural values of thrift, self-control and tiao or jingtiao xixuan -careful selection for quality (Hanser, 2010;Lin & Wang, 2010;Liu et al, 2011;Podoshen et al, 2011) -shape consumers' schemes of perception and appreciation. Coffee is relatively new to China, as many respondents noted; thus, Starbucks consumers may not feel competent to judge its quality by their own palate or range of coffee-drinking experience.…”

“…Research on contemporary China has linked the increased access to foreign goods in the wake of gaige kaifang (reform and openingup policy) to new forms of middle-class identity and an emerging consumer culture (e.g. Croll, 2006;Elfick, 2011;Lin & Wang, 2010;Tian & Dong, 2011). Running through much of this literature is the question of what such changes portend for Chinese culture.…”

Virtual Goods Markets and Economy in China: A Historic Account

“…Exposure to international products and services, the cultural influences brought by the multinational companies, and advertisements on radio and TV have introduced the modern lifestyle to the Chinese consumers. For example, Lin and Wang (2010) noted the subtle changes in cultural values and advertising strategies visible in Chinese commercials which emphasize youth and modernity appeals, and reflect westernization.…”