The Public Sector's Perspective on Procuring Public Works Projects ‐ Comparing the Views of Practitioners in Hong Kong and Australia

Abstract

Abstract. Hong Kong has been one of the early jurisdictions to adopt Public Private Partnership (PPP) model for delivering large public infrastructure projects. The development of this procurement approach in Hong Kong has followed an intricate path. As such, it is believed that there are a number of areas which are interesting to unveil. As part of a comprehensive research study looking at implementing PPPs, interviews with experienced local industrial practitioners from the public sector were conducted to realize their perspective on the topic of procuring public works projects. Amongst these interviews, fourteen were launched government officials and advisers. The interview findings show that the majority of the Hong Kong and Australian interviewees had previously conducted some kind of research in the field of PPP. Both groups of interviewees agreed that "PPPs gain private sector's added efficiency/expertise/management skills" when compared to projects procured traditionally. Also, both groups of interviewees felt that projects best suited to use PPP are those that have an "Economic business case". The interviewees believed that "Contractor's performance" could be used as key performance indicators for PPP projects. A large number of critical success factors were identified by the interviewees for PPP projects; two of these were similar for both groups of interviewees. These included "Project objectives well defined" and "Partnership spirit/commitment/trust". Finally it was found that in-house guidance materials were more common in the organizations of the Australian interviewees compared to the Hong Kong ones. This paper studies the views of the public sector towards the topic of PPPs in Hong Kong and Australia, which helps to answer some of the queries that both academics and the private sector in these jurisdictions are keen to know. As a result the private sector can be more prepared when negotiating with the public sector and realise their needs better, academics on the other hand are provided a wider perspective of this topic benefiting the research industry at large.

Determining Appropriate Government Guarantees for Concession Contract: Lessons Learned From 10 PPP Projects in China

“…Public Private Partnership (PPP) is a well-established procurement model for delivering public infrastructure projects in which "both the public and the private investor will contribute their expertise and resources to the project and share the risks involved" (Cheung et al 2010). Successful implementation of PPP demands many prerequisites, such as a business-friendly environment, a wellestablished legal system, a clean administration and open markets (Sobhiyah et al 2009).…”

Proactive Measures of Governmental Debt Guarantees to Facilitate Public-Private Partnerships Project

“…Although the public sector is risk-averse and tries to transfer most of risks to private in many PPP projects (Yuan et al 2010), government support for such projects is common in both developing and developed countries, and is deemed as one of the critical success factors (Chen, Doloi 2008;Chowdhury, Charoenngam 2009;Cheung et al 2010). The literature proposes several explanations for this governmental decision.…”

“…The role of Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) in providing public services has become a common alternative for policy makers around the world (Ock et al 2005;Russell et al 2006;Sungmin et al 2009;Cheung et al 2010;Tang et al 2010;Yuan et al 2010). According to the Private Participation in Infrastructure Database (WorldBank 2010), investment commitments in PPP road projects grew from US$ 7 billion in 2005 to a new peak of US$ 16.7 billion in 2008.…”

Risk Management Framework for Build, Operate and Transfer (Bot) Projects in Kuwait

“…In this agreement, usually both the public and private sector will contribute their expertise and resources to the project and share the risks involved, Cheung et al (2010). The Public-Private Partnership, (PPP), projects fall into two main groups, consisting of general and project risks (Loosemore 2007;Loosemore et al 2006).…”