“…A few examples can be found in contexts of 3D model editors, as proposed by Denning et al [17] or Doboš et al [18], that use timelines to display the step-by-step construction of the model. Although, S4D visualization tools sometimes use timelines as sliders, juxtaposing 1dimension additional information with the 3D spatial data, as in Duran et al [21] work or RubberSlider [12], which uses a VR adjustable slider to explore a timeline and display 3D data. The lack of design guidelines for the visualization of S4D data using timelines motivated the extension of the design space from Brehmer et al [5].…”