The Value of Patch Testing With Shoe Material Samples in Patients Suspected of Shoe Allergic Contact Dermatitis

Abstract

Background: Patch testing is the standard diagnostic tool for shoe allergic contact dermatitis (ACD). As shoe materials change over time, utilizing commercial allergen series might be ineffective. However, because testing with patients' shoe samples is laborious, its value is questioned.Objective: The aim of this study was to ascertain the benefits of patch testing with patients' shoes by comparing the frequencies of patch-test positivity of shoes and shoe-related allergens in baseline series for suspected shoe ACD patients.Methods: A retrospective study was conducted of patients with clinically suspected shoe ACD who underwent patch testing with baseline series and shoe samples 2000 to 2019.Results: Almost half of the cohort (77 of 178; 43.3%) was diagnosed with shoe ACD. Of those 77, 48 (62.3%) were positive to shoe-related allergens from the baseline series, whereas 53 (68.8%) were positive to their shoe materials. The prevalence of tests positive to shoe material but negative to shoe-related allergens was 29 of 77 (37.7%). The most common shoe-related allergens were potassium dichromate (7.9%), carba mix (6.8%), and mercapto mix (6.7%).Conclusions: Patch testing with shoe materials increased the diagnostic yield by 37.7 percent. To diagnose shoe ACD, testing of shoe materials may compensate for unknown, scarce, or novel allergens not in the baseline series.

Allergic contact dermatitis to footwear in Thailand: Prevalence, clinical characteristics and common allergens

“…Patch testing with shoe pieces plays a crucial role in detecting footwear ACD, as exemplified by our previous study that demonstrated a 37.7% increase in diagnostic yield through such testing with shoe materials 8 . In the current investigation, almost a quarter of the patients showed a positive reaction when patch tested with shoe pieces.…”

“…For shoe pieces, thin pieces of shoes at the area of correlated dermatitis were cut to approximately 1 cm 2 and soaked in water for 15 min 8 . The placement was on the upper arm using surgical tape (3 M Blenderm, Borken, Germany) for 4 days.…”

“…For shoe pieces, thin pieces of shoes at the area of correlated dermatitis were cut to approximately 1 cm 2 and soaked in water for 15 min. 8 The placement was on the upper arm using surgical tape (3 M Blenderm, Borken, Germany) for 4 days. The results of shoerelated allergens were categorised into the following groups: rubber chemicals, adhesives, leather, dye, biocides, metal and others.…”