“…Additionally, Ridge 1 is continuous and there are no indicators of sediment flow, such as inter-platform seaway, reef passes or slope debris, in contrast to other reefs described from seismic data (e.g., Courgeon et al, 2016;Posamentier et al, 2010Posamentier et al, , 2022Schlager, 2005). Drowned reefal ridges described in the literature tend to be only a few 100's metres or a few kilometres long (e.g., Jorry et al, 2016;Khanna et al, 2017;Mallarino et al, 2021;Rovere et al, 2018) or to be composed of joint and isolated pinnacles (Abbey et al, 2011), and as such are dissimilar to Ridge 1. Finally, lithological data do not fully support a reefal origin, as no bioconstructed crust, lithified coral conglomerate or other indicators of reefal bioconstruction were observed along the time-equivalent outcrops (Riera et al, 2021) or from well data.…”