Top-down/bottom-up approach for developing sustainable development indicators for mining: application to the Arlit uranium mines (Niger)

Abstract

Minerals extraction is related to complex sustainable-development issues that are subject to international and local controversies. Debates and decisions need to be based on objective and comparative elements. Defining strong indicators for assessing impacts and performances of mining sites thus appears necessary to inform and support the decision-making process for stakeholders. In recent years, many indicator sets have been developed on an international level based on top-down approaches. But they commonly lack legitimacy for stakeholders and adequacy to specific site issues.They thus need to be complemented by the consultation of local actors concerned by such mining activity, in order to define indicators that are closer to the needs and contexts of the specific sites. This is the goal of the work reported in this paper, undertaken at the Arlit uranium mines in Niger. Our objective was to define indicators that are understood and accepted by all actors, as a basis for robust and transparent assessment of the impacts and performances of mining sites across the four sustainable development dimensions, and at local, regional and national scales.

Water Supply and Sewage Services Regulation Indicators in Poverty Areas: Structure and Application Process in Cubatão-Sp, Brazil

“…On the other hand, a more participatory approach to the choice of indicators may incorporate the individual values of stakeholders to the decision-making process (CHAMARET et al, 2007;MAGEE et al, 2013), which is a fairer way to represent the interests of indicators' users (MAGEE et al, 2013). This approach also allows weighing the local knowledge to be applied to the decision-making process.…”

The Evolution of a Sustainability Leader: The Development of Strategic and Boundary Spanning Organizational Innovation Capabilities in Woolworths

“…Fig 2005 ). The emphasis was therefore on developing a 'bottom-up' list of indicators focusing on internal stakeholders, though arguably more could have been done to include external stakeholders in this process (Branzei and Rao 2007 ;Chamaret et al 2007 ).…”

Abductions, kidnappings and killings in the Sahel and Sahara

“…Multinational corporations (MNCs) introduce heavy machines, materials, pollution in the desert, as well as increased demands on what little water is available. All this is for one purpose: the extraction of oil, natural gas, uranium, iron ore, and the search for other mineral resources (Bonte 2001, Chamaret et al 2007, Guichaoua 2009). In their impressive 4 × 4 vehicles, international non-governmental organisations (NGOs) occasionally visit to distribute medicines, food, and other implements for development projects (Sørbø et al 1998, Sørbø 2010.…”