Universal access to essential medicines as part of the right to health: a cross-national comparison of national laws, medicines policies, and health system indicators

Abstract

Background: Access to essential medicines for the world's poor and vulnerable has made little progress since 2000, except for a few specific medicines such as antiretrovirals for HIV/ AIDS. Human rights principles written into national law can create a supportive environment for universal access to medicines; however, systematic research and policy guidance on this topic is lacking. Objective: To examine how international human rights law and WHO's essential medicines policies are embedded in national law for medicines affordability and financing, and interpreted and implemented in practice to promote universal access to essential medicines. Methods: This thesis consists of (1) a cross-national content analysis of 192 national constitutions, 71 national medicines policies, and legislation for universal health coverage (UHC) from 16 mostly low-and middle-income countries; (2) a case study of medicines litigation in Uruguay, and (3) a follow-up report of eight right to health indicators for access to medicines from 195 countries. Results: Some, but not all, of the 12 principles from human rights law and WHO's policy are embedded in national UHC law and medicines policies (part 1). Even the most rights-compliant legislation for access to medicines is subject to the unique and inconsistent interpretation of domestic courts, which may be inconsistent with the right to health in international law (part 2). Many national health systems for which data were available still fail to meet the official targets for eight indicators of access to medicines (part 3). Conclusions: International human rights law and WHO policy are embedded in national law for essential medicines and practically implemented in national health systems. Law makers can use these findings and the example texts in this thesis as a starting point for writing and monitoring governments' rights-based legal commitments for access to medicines. Future research should study the effect of national law on access to medicines and population health.

Anesthetic drug shortages in Pakistan: a multicentre nationwide survey

“…They further state that access to essential medications is an indicator of the right to health. 14 In our survey, approximately one out of two anesthesia practitioners in Pakistan reported anesthetic drug shortages of some kind in their workplace during the first six months of 2021. Fifty-seven percent of respondents mentioned using an inferior drug that may have affected the delivery of anesthetic care.…”

How should implementation of the human right to health be assessed? A scoping review of the public health literature from 2000 to 2021

“…The most comprehensive attempt to construct indicators of the implementation of the right to health, in terms of anchoring of the method in human rights principles, the number of indicators, and the diversity of areas concerned, was published in 2008 under the authorship of the first UN Special Rapporteur on the right to health [10]. Some of these indicators were used in two later studies [19,20].…”

The viewpoints of medical sciences wealth creators regarding the wealth creation strategies and path in medical sciences universities

“…In addition to the fact that we should be cautious to this point and do not neglect moral and ethical considerations of health as a wealth; because, according to the other studies, promoting community health is also defined as wealth creation and is of a great value in medical sciences. [ 15 ]…”