Untying the Growth Index to Relieve the σ8 Discomfort

Abstract

The matter fluctuation parameter σ8 is, by model construction, degenerate with the growth index γ. Here, we study the effect on the cosmological parameter constraints by treating each independently from one another, considering σ8 as a free and non-derived parameter along with a free γ. We then try to constrain all parameters using three probes that span from deep to local redshifts, namely the CMB spectrum, the growth measurements from redshift space distortions fσ8, and the galaxy cluster counts. We also aim to assess the impact of this relaxation on the σ8 tension between its inferred CMB value in comparison to that obtained from local cluster counts. We also propose a more sophisticated correction, along with the classical one, that takes into account the impact of cosmology on the growth measurements when the parameters are varied in the Monte Carlo process, which consist in adjusting the growth to keep the observed power spectrum, integrated over all angles and scales, as invariant with the background evolution. We found by using the classical correction that untying the two parameters does not shift the maximum likelihood of either σ8 or γ, but it rather enables larger bounds with respect to when σ8 is a derived parameter, and that when considering CMB + fσ8, or when further combining with cluster counts albeit with tighter bounds. Precisely, we obtain σ8=0.809±0.043 and γ=0.613±0.046 in agreement with Planck’s constraint for the former and compatible with ΛCDM for the latter but with bounds wide enough to accommodate both values subject to the tensions. Allowing for massive neutrinos does not change the situation much. On the other hand, considering a tiered correction yields σ8=0.734±0.013 close to ∼1 σ for the inferred local values albeit with a growth index of γ=0.636±0.022 at ∼2 σ from its ΛCDM value. Allowing for massive neutrinos in this case yielded σ8=0.756±0.024, still preferring low values but with much looser constraints on γ=0.549±0.048 and a slight preference for Σmν∼0.19. We conclude that untying σ8 and γ helps in relieving the discomfort on the former between the CMB and local probes, and that careful analysis should be followed when using data products treated in a model-dependent way.

Seven Hints That Early-Time New Physics Alone Is Not Sufficient to Solve the Hubble Tension

“…Nevertheless, it is fair to say that we remain far from a compelling solution to the Hubble tension. Leaving aside their theoretical motivation, none of the models proposed so far have succeeded in accommodating a higher H 0 while maintaining a good fit to all available data, or not worsening other tensions (e.g., the "S 8 discrepancy" [567][568][569][570][571]). Tongue-in-cheek, I would say that the statement "the Hubble tension calls for early-time new physics" may have been elevated to somewhat of a mantra in the community, and more often than not interpreted a bit too literally.…”

Special Issue on Modified Gravity Approaches to the Tensions of ΛCDM: Goals and Highlights

“…By selecting models with a unique shift-symmetric friction term, their work demonstrates how these theories can significantly mitigate the discrepancy between local and early Universe measurements of the Hubble constant, offering new pathways for resolving this longstanding cosmological puzzle. Ziad Sakr's research (contribution 2 [70]) focuses on untangling the σ 8 discomfort by independently analyzing the matter fluctuation parameter σ 8 and the growth index γ. His innovative approach treats σ 8 as a free parameter, distinct from its traditional derivation, revealing how this separation can lead to more accurate constraints on cosmological parameters and offering a novel perspective on the growth tension within the ΛCDM framework.…”