Urban Informality in the Paris Climate Agreement: Content Analysis of the Nationally Determined Contributions of Highly Urbanized Developing Countries

Abstract

Climate change related events affect informal settlements, or slums, disproportionally more than other areas in a city or country. This article investigates the role of slums in the nationally determined contributions (NDCs) for the Paris Agreement of a selected group of 28 highly urbanized developing countries. Content analysis and descriptive statistics were used to analyze first the general content in these NDCs and second the proposed role, or lack thereof, of slums in these documents. The results show that for most of the analyzed countries, context-based climate policies for slums are not part of the strategies presented in the NDCs. We argue that a lack of policies involving informal settlements might limit the capacity of developing countries to contribute to the main goals of the Paris Agreement, as these settlements are significant portions of their urban populations. One of the hopeful prospects of the NDCs is that they will be reviewed in 2020 for the 26th Conference of the Parties (COP26). With this paper, we aim to stimulate discussions about the crucial role that informal settlements should play in the NDCs of developing countries in the background of the synergies required between climate change actions and sustainable development.

Allocation of Greenhouse Gas Emissions Using the Fairness Principle: A Multi-Country Analysis

“…In terms of financial performance of firms, Oestreich and Tsiakas [49] report a large and statistically significant carbon premium in stock returns. However, studies on Europe [50][51][52] and the USA [53,54] are less common, and those presenting a more global, holistic perspective, such as ours, are particularly scarce [55,56].…”

Revealing the Contribution of Informal Settlements to Climate Change Mitigation in Latin America: A Case Study of Isidro Fabela, Mexico City

“…Mexico City is the secondlargest Megacity of Latin America and has higher levels of economic development [64,65] than many of its counterparts in the Global South, but it also has high levels of urban poverty and inequality [66]. Thus, this comprehensive examination of energy and resource consumption, in Mexico City's colonia popular, can serve as a reference for other Latin American cities and beyond in the Global South, which house the largest populations of slums dwellers [7,8].…”

“…Previous research on informal settlements and climate change primarily focused on adaptation strategies to address the sensitivity of precarious infrastructure to extreme climate events [4][5][6]. There is little understanding of the significance of informal settlements for climate change mitigation [7,8]. Previous research explored the mitigation potential of retrofitting residential buildings, erected by architects and contractors, in cities of the North [9][10][11][12][13].…”

Evolution and Management of Illegal Settlements in Mid-Sized Towns. The Case of Sierra de Santa Bárbara (Plasencia, Spain)

“…The literature about informal settlements focuses primarily on land grabs and on the creation of slums, which are a common phenomenon in developing countries and even in developed ones, some of them included in the Global North [1]. Then, this type of informality is associated with marginality [2][3][4]. Even the UN [5] agrees with this idea in its New Urban Agenda.…”