Urologists’ Attitudes Regarding Information Sharing with Prostate Cancer Patients—Is There a Common Ground for Collaboration with Family Physicians?

Abstract

Clinicians often fail to adequately meet prostate cancer patients' information needs, and patients may receive different kinds of information from their doctors. This study aims to describe urologists' attitudes regarding information sharing with prostate cancer patients and to compare these findings with the previously published attitudes of Israeli family physicians. A questionnaire (11 items) was mailed to 87 board-certified practicing urologists. Fifty-four physicians (66%) completed the questionnaires. Sixty-one percent of respondents stated that patients should be told the complete truth about their disease. Ninety-six percent of respondents felt competent at breaking bad news and stated they would discuss emotions with patients. The majority of physicians would provide general information when referring for a medical procedure, discussing treatment options or a patient's prognosis. Fifty-seven percent of respondents preferred that patients be autonomous in their decision making. Only 26% of respondents believed that family physicians should communicate medical information to patients at the preliminary diagnostic stages. There was no significant difference in the attitudes expressed by urologists and family physicians towards the amount of information they would share with prostate cancer patients and in their preferences regarding treatment decision making. Urologists in Israel recognize the importance of sharing information with prostate cancer patients. Although urologists share similar attitudes with family physicians, they do not recognize the role that family physicians play in caring for prostate cancer patients. Further studies are needed to design and implement effective ways to improve the communication and collaboration between urologists and family physicians for the benefit of prostate cancer patients.

Physician attitudes toward shared decision making: A systematic review

“…No strong preference for one treatment option [29] Support evidence in favor of one specific treatment option [31,30,3] Physician mentors do not support the use of SDM [33] Patient-related Cognitively able [34] Cognitively unable to participate [31,37,35,23,36] Poor adherence [37] Poor adherence [23] Desire to be involved in decision [34,23] Unwilling to participate [37] Informed about condition [23] Limited insight into condition OR treatment [23,45,33] Less educated [33] Children [35] Condition-and treatmentrelated Chronic disease [31,34,66] Chronic pain [35] Cancer screening and treatment [58,64,59,63,44,65] Emergency medicine [31,34] End of life care [31] Hospital care [specific to psychiatry] [23] Severe disease [34] Diagnostic procedures [23] Multiple treatment options exist [34,38,39,55] Pediatric intensive care [45] Treatment options may affect patient's lifestyle [38,36] support SDM,...…”

Attitudes, beliefs and perceptions regarding truth disclosure of cancer-related information in the Middle East: A review

“…61% of respondents stated that patients should be told the complete truth about their disease and 96% felt competent at breaking bad news. The comparison between urologist and family physicians attitudes retrieved no difference (Cohen Castel et al, 2011). In conclusion, the Israeli and Palestinian populations are known to be heterogeneous in their ethnic, cultural, and religious background.…”

Comunicação de notícias difíceis no contexto do cuidado em oncologia: revisão integrativa de literatura [Giving bad news in the context of cancer care: integrative literature review]

“…Vale destacar que capacitação para comunicação com clientes e familiares acometidos por doenças graves e ameaçadoras da vida estão sendo cada vez mais valorizados. Os profissionais que participam desses treinamentos têm conseguido manejar mais adequadamente o atendimento a essas pessoas 9,18 .…”

“…A necessidade, cada vez mais constante, do treinamento das habilidades de comunicação dos profissionais de saúde tem possibilitado melhora da empatia e a diminuição da sobrecarga daqueles que precisam frequentemente comunicar más notícias 9,18 .…”