Kti12 (Kluyveromyces lactis toxin insensitive 12) is an evolutionary highly conserved ATPase, crucial for the tRNA-modification activity of the eukaryotic Elongator complex. The protein consists of an N-terminal ATPase and a C-terminal tRNA-binding domain, which are connected by a flexible linker. The precise role of the linker region and its involvement in the communication between the two domains and their activities remain elusive. Here, we analyzed all available Kti12 protein sequences and report the discovery of a subset of Kti12 proteins with abnormally long linker regions. These Kti12 proteins are characterized by a co-occurring lysine to leucine substitution in their Walker A motif, previously thought to be invariable. We show that the K14L substitution lowers the affinity to ATP, but does not affect the catalytic activity of Kti12 at high ATP concentrations. We compare the activity of mutated variants of Kti12 in vitro with complementation assays in vivo in yeast. Ultimately, we compared Kti12 to other known p-loop ATPase family members known to carry a similar deviant Walker A motif. Our data establish Kti12 of Eurotiomycetes as an example of eukaryotic ATPase harboring a significantly deviating but still functional Walker A motif.