Use of Theoretical Frameworks as a Pragmatic Guide for Mixed Methods Studies

Abstract

There is a growing acceptance of the utility of mixed methods in health sciences but there is no widely accepted set of ideas in regard to use of a conceptual or theoretical framework to guide inquiry. Few mixed methods health science articles report the use of such a framework. Lack of available conceptual maps provided by theoretical frameworks, necessary intricacy of design, and the qualitative “black box” tradition all contribute to a dearth of methodological guidance in such studies. This article uses a funded National Institutes of Health study as an example to explain the utility of a theoretical framework in conceptualizing a study, making design decisions such as sampling and recruitment, collecting and analyzing data, and data interpretation.

Worry Among Mexican American Caregivers of Community-Dwelling Elders

“…We enhanced transferability through congruency with our theoretical framework, specific descriptions of our data collection and analytic procedures, and verbatim exemplars, so that other researchers could evaluate the trustworthiness of our conclusions for themselves (Evans et al, 2011; Miles & Huberman, 1994). …”

“…The parent project relied on life course perspective to examine cultural and contextual differences, transitions, turning points, and adaptive strategies in caregiving (Evans, Crogan, Belyea, & Coon, 2009; George, 2003; Wethington, 2005). Additional details about the theoretical framework, the methodological approach, and methods used in this study are available else-where (Evans, Coon, & Ume, 2011). …”

Represión estatal entre las filas del catolicismo argentino durante la última dictadura militar. Una mirada del conjunto y de los perfiles de las víctimas

“…Siguiendo un diseño de métodos combinados (QUAL þ quant), estas líneas generales elaboradas sobre un conjunto específico de víctimas no son generalizables al universo de víctimas del terrorismo de Estado pero, en la medida en que esclarecen algunos mecanismos de la racionalidad represiva, pueden ser sugerentes para el abordaje de otros grupos de víctimas. 7 Los obstáculos encontrados para cuantificar este grupo de víctimas no son distintos de los que se presentan en los trabajos sobre el conjunto de víctimas del terrorismo de Estado. Una de las consecuencias del carácter clandestino de la represión fue su carácter incompleto, subrepticio y descentralizado del registro de los hechos de violencia perpetrados.…”

Multiple and mixed methods in formative evaluation: Is more better? Reflections from a South African study

“…They also allow the corroboration, or triangulation, of findings [11, 16, 18, 19]. However, these approaches raise a number of challenges including assembling a research team with skills and experience across multiple methods [20]; acquiring the resources needed to implement data collection using multiple strategies [21]; and undertaking analysis of data collected using multiple approaches [22]. …”