Users’ Opinion About a Virtual Reality System as an Adjunct to Psychological Treatment for Stress-Related Disorders: A Quantitative and Qualitative Mixed-Methods Study

Abstract

This study aims to explore patients’ and therapists’ attitudes about the psychological treatment they received (patients) or applied (therapists). The treatments were standard CBT protocols for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), complicated grief (CG), or adjustment disorders (ADs), depending on each patient diagnosis. The treatments were delivered following a traditional format or supported by a virtual reality (VR) system “EMMA’s WORLD” designed for the treatment of stress-related disorders. “EMMA’s WORLD” is a VR application in which patients can explore negative experiences using different virtual elements that can be customized to make them more meaningful to the user. The sample was composed of two groups: the “professionals” (N = 10) were all clinical psychologists who applied the same psychological treatment in both the traditional format (“traditional condition”) and using the VR system (“EMMA” condition). The second group consisted of a sample of patients (N = 50) who met the criteria for at least one of three different diagnoses: PTSD (N = 15), CG (N = 15), or AD (N = 20). 25 patients received treatment in the traditional format and 25 supported by the VR system. The patients were asked about their expectations (before treatment) and satisfaction (after treatment) with the treatment they received. All the therapists were asked their opinions about both treatment conditions. A mixed-methods approach using quantitative and qualitative methodologies was used. In both conditions, high scores were observed, and the patient’s opinions were even better when they have already received the treatments. A more pronounced pre-test–post-test change in the EMMA therapy group than in the traditional group was observed. EMMA’s World was well-accepted by both patients and therapists, and it helped to foster motivation in patients, while helping the therapist to apply the treatment. Thus, VR can be useful as an adjunct tool to enhance the treatment.

Co‐designing a virtual world with young people to deliver social cognition therapy in early psychosis

“…Service users supported novel methods of engagement of people who may be suffering in isolation and found virtual worlds to delivery therapy acceptable. This finding is consistent with previous studies that employed similar delivery methods (Brewer et al, 2017;Guillén, Baños, & Botella, 2018;Rosal et al, 2014).…”

Can Between-Session Homework Be Delivered Digitally? A Pilot Randomized Clinical Trial of CBT for Adjustment Disorders

“…Furthermore, EMMA’s World has been found to be well accepted by both patients and therapists. It helped to foster motivation in patients, while helping the therapist to apply the treatment [26]. Thus, VR can be also useful as an adjunct tool to enhance the treatment.…”

Translating performative mediated art into virtual reality: A case study

“…In addition to mindfulness training already referred to, studies have shown that VR has been used for managing the well-being of dementia patients (Rose et al 2018). Guillén et al (2018) have also highlighted the possibilities and importance of customizable VR content for enhancing stress-management therapy with positive usability results and feedback from participants. VR research focusing on restorative and relaxation applications (Blum et al 2019;Valtchanov et al 2010;Roche et al 2019) has also shown useful and positive findings in improving mental wellness, especially in the context of physical illness or disability.…”