Using design theory to foster innovative cross-disciplinary research: Lessons learned from a research network focused on antimicrobial use and animal microbes’ resistance to antimicrobials

Abstract

Dealing with the major societal and research challenges related to antimicrobial use will require cross-disciplinary research and strong relationships between researchers and stakeholders. Design theories, such as the concept-knowledge (C-K) theory, can help spur the emergence of innovation. Here, our objective was to examine how the C-K theory could promote the development of novel, cross-disciplinary research projects on antimicrobial use and animal microbes’ resistance to antimicrobials. A French research network (R2A2; Réseau Recherche Antibiotiques Animal) was created whose goal was to foster cross-disciplinary research and scientific discussion on these topics. The R2A2 network hosted general meetings and thematic workshops, during which participants brainstormed using C-K diagrams. The network's performance was evaluated through the evolution of C-K diagrams, project creation, and participant interviews. R2A2 led to the creation of a minimum of eight research projects. The participants felt network events facilitated interactions and collaborations with researchers in different disciplines. The R2A2 network has opened new avenues of research into several important topics: antimicrobial use on farms, the environmental impacts of antimicrobials, animal immunity, and alternative treatments. The keys to its success were: (i) participant interest; (ii) the use of C-K design theory to encourage cross-disciplinary thinking; (iii) the aim of fostering several small projects rather than one large project; and (iv) network responsiveness to participant needs with regards to meeting and workshop topics. C-K theory served a key role in promoting cross-disciplinary thinking on topics at the interface between research and stakeholder interests.

Mapping Twenty Years of Antimicrobial Resistance Research Trends

“…The conceptual structure of AMR research is highly heterogeneous due to its cross-disciplinary nature, making it difficult to grasp the overall picture and interrelatedness of research topics. 8 However, the structure of the AMR field is essential to identify temporal and geographical trends, assess funding effects, and help guide future research and funding.…”

Comment faciliter la construction et la conduite des projets interdisciplinaires : retour d’expérience d’un programme de recherche sur la gestion intégrée de la santé des animaux en élevage

“…], 2015). Cette approche peut mobiliser la conception innovante 4 (Hatchuel et al, 2017), ce qui a été le cas au sein du réseau R2A2 sur les questions posées par l'usage des antibiotiques en élevage (Vourc'h et al, 2018) et a grandement facilité le travail collectif. Elle a permis de rediscuter le statut des connaissances et de concevoir une situation de recherche qui n'était plus celle de départ, décentrant la réflexion disciplinaire (Ledford, 2015 ;Brown et al, 2015).…”

Six Sigma with C-K theory for innovations in operational excellence: a case study

“…In other words, the knowledge space consists of all the knowledge of Six Sigma expert, i.e. the knowledge of the product, service, process, marketing, operational, technical, legal and the set of propositions with logical status (Vourch et al, 2018). The C is the concept which is the unknown proposition.…”