Using eco-design tools: An overview of experts' practices

Abstract

International audienceThe practice of eco-design requires relating traditional design criteria to new environmental criteria. So far, few studies have investigated the nature and singularities of eco-design. This article provides some elements of response based upon the redesign of a consumer product (disposable razor). The study was conducted by three groups of experienced eco-designers using existing eco-design tools (SIMAPRO, ECOFAIRE, ECODESIGN PILOT). A protocol analysis with a three-level coding of transactions was carried out for this purpose. Two main findings are reported: (1) environmental assessment, solution finding and strategy definition are the activities which differentiate eco-design from design; (2) environmental initial assessment and strategy definition are more heavily influenced by eco-designers’ expertise than support from tools.Highlights► This study investigates the nature and singularities of eco-design compared to traditional design. ► A protocol analysis based on the observation of three experienced eco-designers' teams is conducted. ► Each team implements a different existing eco-design tool to redesign the same consumer product. ► Environmental assessment, solution finding and strategy definition appear to be specific to eco-design practice. ► Initial environmental assessment and strategy definition are heavily influenced by eco-designers' expertise

Maquinaria de punto: desarrollo y vigencia en el diseño actual

“…La fabricación de prendas de punto con la técnica tradicional de "prendas menguadas" (fully fashioned en terminología anglosajona), hace que el desperdicio de fibras sea prácticamente nulo, frente a la confección de tejidos de calada confeccionados por corte y cosido que generan un desperdicio de tejido de entre un 50% a un 17% (Sissons, 2010) (figura 10). Como indican Vallet y Eynard, para encontrar soluciones de diseño centradas en el eco-diseño, uno de los factores principales en la estrategia frente al impacto ambiental es la reducción del uso de materias primas (Vallet et al, 2013). Por tanto, el diseño y fabricación de prendas con la técnica aportada por las tricotosas permite actuar de raíz eliminando residuos y ahorrando materiales, siendo así una técnica dentro de los parámetros de diseño sostenible.…”

Product-Centric Simulation-Based Design for Recycling: Case of LED Lamp Recycling

“…A quick analysis using standard MFA-based Ecodesign methodology [8] has shown that the recycling rates calculated for the five designs using such an approach is significantly higher than that estimated by the methodology in this paper. It is obvious that this produces no tangible design improvement suggestions to the design engineer.…”

“…Linking the product designer and metallurgical processing as shown in Fig. 1 is hardly possible with the simplified approaches being suggested and discussed by Vallet et al [8], Karlsson and Luttropp [9], Luttropp and Lagerstedt [4], and Bonvoisin et al [10]. Predicting the recovery of the multitude of elements from complex products shown in Fig.…”

Sustainability Issues in Turkish Packaging

“…Moreover, the designer's expertise in sustainable design is more influential than sustainable design tools in defining environmental assessment and strategy [12].…”