Vaccine Coverage and Effectiveness in a School-Based Varicella Outbreak in Jinan Prefecture, Shandong Province

Abstract

Background: Licheng District of Jinan Prefecture reported a school-based varicella outbreak. We conducted an investigation to analyze the epidemiology and scope of the outbreak, determine varicella vaccine coverage on the school campus, and estimate varicella vaccine effectiveness (VE). Methods: In the epidemiological investigation, we determined the attack rate, the clinical manifestations of varicella cases, and histories of prior varicella disease and varicella vaccination. We tested students for presence of serum IgM antibodies, and we attempted to isolate the varicella virus from vesicular fluid samples. We used chi-square to compare incidences between classes and floors. VE was estimated using a retrospective cohort study. Results: There were 13 varicella cases in the outbreak. All were among fourth grade students - twelve in Class 7 and one in Class 6. The attack rate in the two classrooms was 14.3% (13/91). Clinical symptoms were rash (100%) and fever (46.15%). All cases were reported within one average incubation period, and the epidemic curve suggested common exposure. Six of the 13 cases previously received one dose of varicella vaccine with a median time between vaccination and infection of 9 years; the other seven cases had not been vaccinated. Varicella vaccine coverage with one or more doses was 81.31%; 2-dose coverage was 38.15%. The median age of receipt of dose 1 was 1.18 years, and median age for receiving dose 2 was 5.12 years. One-dose varicella VE was 73.2% (95% confidence interval: 37.0%, 88.6%), and two-dose VE was 100%. Conclusions: Varicella vaccine coverage has been gradually increasing in recent years, as ≥1-dose and 2-dose coverage rates are higher in younger children than older children. High one-dose vaccination coverage limited the outbreak scope and led to the breakthrough cases being mild. Mild cases were difficult to detect in a timely manner. Varicella vaccine was highly effective, with 1-dose VE of 73% nine years after vaccination and 2-dose VE of 100%. We strongly recommended that all school students receive two doses of varicella vaccine.

Epidemiological Characteristics of Varicella under Different Immunisation Strategies in Suzhou Prefecture, Jiangsu Province

“…However, VarV-1 could not interrupt the transmission of varicella compared to VarV-2. VarV-2 vaccination has become the preferred choice because of the high breakthrough rate of VarV-1 [ 34 ]. The evaluation of the immunogenicity and safety of live attenuated VarV-2 manufactured by China vaccine corporation revealed that varicella virus has good immune persistence for one to three years after initial immunisation.…”

Exploring the Ethical Dimensions of Mandatory Immunization Discourse for School Attendance in Indonesia

“…Not only is coverage among school children is important, but also proper vaccination in terms of completeness in primary and boosters were shown to be important to prevent sustained transmission within the school (31,32). Nevertheless, when outbreaks within schools happened, studies also show that vaccination, even a single dose that taken years ago, was able to protect children against severe cases of disease (33).…”

The epidemiology of varicella and effectiveness of varicella vaccine in Ganyu, China: a long-term community surveillance study

“…Live-attenuated varicella vaccines were introduced in China in 1997 and have been recommended for children 12 months through 12 years old with a single-dose regimen [ 6 ]. However, the national strategy for varicella vaccination in China is to encourage people to receive the vaccine through the principle of voluntarism, and a meta-analysis showed that the overall one-dose varicella vaccine coverage was 61.1%, ranging from 20.8% to 97.8% [ 7 ]. With moderate vaccination coverage, the incidence of varicella increased from 3.17 per 100,000 in 2005 to 70.14 per 100,000 in 2019 [ 8 , 9 ].…”