Volcanic jets, plumes, and collapsing fountains: evidence from large-scale experiments, with particular emphasis on the entrainment rate

Abstract

The source conditions of volcanic plumes and collapsing fountains are investigated by means of large-scale experiments. In the experiments, gas-particle jets issuing from a cylindrical conduit are forced into the atmosphere at different mass flow rates. Dense jets (high particle volumetric concentration, e.g., C 0 > 0.01) generate collapsing fountains, whose height scales with the squared exit velocity. This is consistent with Bernoulli's equation, which is a good approximation if air entrainment is negligible. In this case, kinetic energy is transformed into potential energy without any significant loss by friction with the atmosphere. The dense collapsing fountain, on hitting the ground, generates an intense shear flow similar to a pyroclastic density current. Dilute hot jets (low particle volumetric concentration, e.g., C 0 < 0.01) dissipate their initial kinetic energy at much smaller heights than those predicted by Bernoulli's equation. This is an indication that part of the total mechanical energy is lost by friction with the atmosphere. Significant air entrainment results in this case, leading to the formation of a buoyant column (plume) from which particles settle similarly to pyroclastic fallout. The direct measurement of entrainment coefficient in the experiments suggests that dense collapsing fountains form only when air entrainment is not significant. This is a consequence of the large density difference between the jet and the atmosphere. Cold dilute experiments result in an entrainment coefficient of about 0.06, which is typical of pure jets of fluid dynamics. Hot dilute experiments result in an entrainment coefficient of about 0.11, which is typical of thermally buoyant plumes. The entrainment coefficients obtained by experiments were used as input data in numerical simulations of fountains and plumes. A numerical model was used to solve the classic top-hat system of governing equations, which averages the field variables (e.g., column velocity and density) across the column. The maximum heights calculated with the model agree well with those observed experimentally, showing that our entrainment coefficients are compatible with a top-hat model. Dimensional analysis of the experimental data shows that a value of 3 for the source densimetric Froude number characterizes the transition between dense collapsing fountains and dilute plumes. This value delimits the source conditions (exit velocity, conduit radius, and particle volumetric concentration) for pyroclastic flow (<3) and fallout (>3). © 2014 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg

Mass eruption rates in pulsating eruptions estimated from video analysis of the gas thrust-buoyancy transition—a case study of the 2010 eruption of Eyjafjallajökull, Iceland

“…This condition needs to be verified during other eruptions, in order to demonstrate the general applicability of our method. The comparison of results obtained for the Eyjafjallajö-kull pulses and the experimental generation of large-scale ash plumes (Dellino et al 2010(Dellino et al , 2014 shows a similarity in the time scale of coupling of kinetic energy to the mass of particles released upon magma fragmentation.…”

“…This fact suggests that the pulses were caused by similar eruption mechanisms, which lead to a similar kinetic energy release after magma fragmentation (e.g., Dürig et al 2012aDürig et al , 2012b. In order to check the link between the pulse emerging from the vent and the post-fragmentation energetics in the conduit, we analyzed the videos of experimentally generated ash pulses under controlled initial conditions that reflect the kinetic energy release in magma fragmentation (Dellino et al 2010;Dellino et al 2014). The same photogrammetric method used for the Eyjafjallajö-kull eruption was employed for analyzing experiments videos (see Fig.…”

“…In the experimental runs, 80-220 kg of both "cold" (298 K) and "hot" (543 K) ash were ejected from a steel conduit (diameter. 0.6 m; length, up to 4 m) by driving pressures between 90 and 180 bar (9-18 MPa) (Dellino et al 2010(Dellino et al , 2014.…”

FPLUME-1.0: An integral volcanic plume model accounting for ash aggregation

“…A vast literature exists regarding the experimental (e.g. Dellino et al, 2014) and numerical (e.g. Suzuki and Koyaguchi, 2009) (Woods, 1993).…”

Investigating Source Conditions and Controlling Parameters of Explosive Eruptions: Some Experimental-Observational- Modelling Case Studies

“…In this section, the results of the first large-scale experiments carried out between 2005 and 2009 by researchers from the University of Bari (Italy) and the University of Würzburg (Germany) are summarized [23][24][25][26]. In particular, relationships between eruptive regimes and source conditions obtained by experiments and their application to hypothetical natural-scale eruptions are presented.…”