We prove that the rational cohomology group
$H^{11}(\overline {\mathcal {M}}_{g,n})$
vanishes unless
$g = 1$
and
$n \geq 11$
. We show furthermore that
$H^k(\overline {\mathcal {M}}_{g,n})$
is pure Hodge–Tate for all even
$k \leq 12$
and deduce that
$\# \overline {\mathcal {M}}_{g,n}(\mathbb {F}_q)$
is surprisingly well approximated by a polynomial in q. In addition, we use
$H^{11}(\overline {\mathcal {M}}_{1,11})$
and its image under Gysin push-forward for tautological maps to produce many new examples of moduli spaces of stable curves with nonvanishing odd cohomology and nontautological algebraic cycle classes in Chow cohomology.