What do patients find helpful in psychotherapy? Implications for the therapeutic relationship in mental health nursing

Abstract

This study examined client perception of the therapeutic impact of two models of therapy delivered by mental health nurses and clinical psychologists respectively - psychodynamic interpersonal therapy (PIT) and cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT). A non-equivalent groups design was used in order to benchmark results against Llewelyn et al.: one group received PIT and the other received CBT. This design was utilized principally because the research was conducted across two practice settings where randomization was not feasible. We used two intact groups in practice research settings that received the therapies as reported in Llewelyn et al. Sixty-one clients receiving CBT or PIT in practice research settings completed a Helpful Aspects of Therapy form after each session in order to measure client perceptions of helpful and hindering events in therapy. Only two out of the 13 impacts were rated as significantly different. PIT clients reported higher levels of 'awareness' than CBT clients, whereas CBT clients reported higher levels of problem solution than PIT clients. The results replicate Llewelyn et al.'s findings in that clients experienced theoretically different models of therapy as broadly similar in their therapeutic impact. We argue that this provides some support for the influence of 'common' rather than 'specific' factors in psychotherapy effectiveness in mental health nursing.

Supporting recovery from hoarding and squalor: insights from a community case study

“…2. Above all else, it is important during the engagement phase that the mental health nurse works hard on adopting an accepting, humanizing approach and focuses on building a strong, trusting and open therapeutic alliance with the consumer and their family (Cahill et al 2013). During this phase, collaboration with a peer support worker may be useful to provide additional support.…”

Implementation of evidence on the nurse-patient relationship in psychiatric wards through a mixed method design: study protocol

“…In this regard, and although nurses are aware of the importance of the TR and how to foster such an alliance, the scientific evidence shows that theoretical knowledge of communicative and interpersonal skills alone is insufficient to develop these skills effectively, and hence to establish an effective therapeutic relationship and provide high-quality nursing care [3, 9, 15–17, 20–23]. …”

Peplau and the brain: Why Interpersonal Neuroscience provides a useful language for the relationship process

“…Research confirms that interventions psychiatric nurses provide e.g., cognitive behavioural, supportive dynamic or interpersonal, are not as important to patients as the relationships that build within the experience [4] . This holds true in intervention scenarios that are short term, such as helping an individual in crisis [5] or in extended therapeutic exploration with individuals dealing with serious mental health issues [6] .…”