What if the local community is already well-off enough? Stakeholders’ conflicts over sustainable tourism development in remote communities

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to explore community involvement in sustainable tourism development (STD) at Siwa Oasis, Egypt, and examines the perspectives of local communities, visitors and governmental decision makers concerning the area’s STD plans. It provides a brief discussion on the stakeholders’ conflict of interest alongside exploring the costs and benefits of STDs for the community. This study examines the area’s problems and challenges and expands the discussion on STD by providing a deep understanding of the oasis context, which involves a broad range of issues. Design/methodology/approach In this exploratory study, 18 semi-structured interviews were conducted with three groups of stakeholders (local community, governmental decision makers and visitors) to investigate the current practices of STD and the future vision for the area. Data were coded and interpreted using thematic analysis. Findings This paper provides empirical insights into how STDs can be practised in an oasis context. It suggests there is a conflict between the governmental vision for the area and the community’s needs that could lead to a failure to implement STDs. Themes related to environmental, social and economic STD dimensions are discussed. The findings provide managerial and practical implications for decision makers on the promotion of STDs in remote communities. Research limitations/implications Because of the chosen research approach, the results may lack generalizability. Therefore, future studies are encouraged to test the study’s propositions further by using a mixed-methods approach, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic. Practical implications This paper has implications for STD within an oasis context, particularly concerning balancing the economic, environmental, political and social aspects of STD. Originality/value This paper fulfils an identified need to study how STD can be practised when most of the local community is already comparatively well-off economically.

Gamification impact on tourists’ pro-sustainability intentions: integration of technology acceptance model (TAM) and the theory of planned behaviour (TPB)

“…Empirical studies confirm the link between knowledge and sustainable behaviour (Chen and Wu, 2015;2022;Chi et al, 2019). Maichum et al (2016) found that people act knowledgeable about sustainability when they think others expect them to be sustainable.…”

“…These destinations offer a wide range of natural and recreational attractions that attract a significant number of tourists who are enthusiastic about sustainable initiatives. Additionally, the Egyptian Government has collaborated with local authorities to promote sustainable tourism development in these destinations, aligning with Egypt's 2030 strategy to improve the environmental footprint of Egypt's tourism industry (Elgammal, 2022).…”

The interplay of tourism economy and food security in dessert-prone agricultural heritage sites

“…The findings of the study reveal a significant gap between the tourism sector and agriculture in terms of their impact on the food security of the Siwa Oasis community (Asham et al ., 2022). It is evident that the current state of tourism is insufficient in providing the necessary support for local communities' food security (Elgammal, 2022). Therefore, there is a pressing need to foster a more integrated approach where tourism and agriculture work hand in hand.…”

Stakeholders’ perception of accessible tourism implementation based on corporate sustainability and responsibility: a SEM-based investigation

“…Stakeholders are any individuals or groups that have the potential to influence or be influenced by an organization’s activities (Freeman, 2010; Elgammal, 2022). They are the entities with whom the organization interacts; thus, defining the dimensions of social responsibility would be impossible without understanding their perspectives (Khuong et al , 2021; Latif and Sajjad, 2018).…”