When to Radiate and When to Stop? Timing Radiographic Surveillance During Nonoperative Treatment of Pediatric Diaphyseal Clavicle Fractures

Abstract

Introduction: Conservative management of most pediatric clavicle fractures is standard. Despite a predictable nonoperative course, evidence about the timeliness of healing is lacking. The goal of this study was to identify when radiographic signs of healing should be expected during routine conservative management of closed pediatric diaphyseal clavicle fractures. Methods: Patients 18 years or younger with an acute diaphyseal clavicle fracture treated at a large academic multispecialty orthopaedic practice over 5 years were retrospectively reviewed. Patients who completed nonoperative management until radiographic and clinical evidence of union were included and categorized into 3 age groups: infants and toddlers (0 to 2 y old), school-aged children (3 to 9 y old), and adolescents (10 to 18 y old). Radiographic healing was analyzed within each 2- to 4-week interval. Results: Among 390 patients, 303 met inclusion criteria. Overall shortening and displacement averaged 0.3±0.6 centimeters and 42.6%±43.0%, respectively. Follow-up averaged 50±24 days with an orthopaedic physician and 16.3±14.8 months for a well-child check. No clinically relevant or statistically significant improvements in the number of cortices bridged were observed in infants/toddlers after 4 weeks (average 20.4±4.3 d from injury), in school-aged children after 8 weeks (average 39.7±7.9 d from injury), or in adolescents after 12 weeks (average 66.4±8.1 d from injury). Conclusions: This study provides an age-dependent timeline during which adequate radiographic healing should be expected in nonoperatively managed pediatric diaphyseal clavicle fractures. Radiographic protocols can be purposefully timed to visualize sufficient healing in infants and toddlers by 4 weeks, school-aged children by 8 weeks, and adolescents by 12 weeks. Level of Evidence: Level III.