We consider the expectation value xWy of the circular BPS Wilson loop in N " 2 superconformal SU pN q gauge theory containing a vector multiplet coupled to two hypermultiplets in rank-2 symmetric and antisymmetric representations. This theory admits a regular large N expansion, is planar-equivalent to N " 4 SYM theory and is expected to be dual to a certain orbifold/orientifold projection of AdS 5 ˆS5 superstring theory. On the string theory side xWy is represented by the path integral expanded near the same AdS 2 minimal surface as in the maximally supersymmetric case. Following the string theory argument in arXiv:2007.08512, we suggest that as in the N " 4 SYM case and in the N " 2 SU pN q ˆSU pN q superconformal quiver theory discussed in arXiv:2102.07696, the coefficient of the leading non-planar 1{N 2 correction in xWy should have the universal λ 3{2 scaling at large 't Hooft coupling. We confirm this prediction by starting with the localization matrix model representation for xWy. We complement the analytic derivation of the λ 3{2 scaling by a numerical high-precision resummation and extrapolation of the weak-coupling expansion using conformal mapping improved Padé analysis.