Women’s sociological research and writing in the AJS in the pre-World War II era

Abstract

Recent revisionist scholarship on the history of sociology suggests that women scholars in the pre-World War II era made distinctive contributions to the development of the field of sociology. Most research, however, has focused on women prominent in their era, whose works might or might nor be typical of all women who published during the same periods. Furthermore, few studies have made explicit comparisons between works by women and by men writing in this same era, so it has been difficult to sort out gender effects from historical era effects. This study explores writings by women and men in the first volumes of the American Journal of Sociolog~ from 1895 through 1940. As the oldest continuously published sociology journal in the U.S., AJS played a central role in the development of American sociology. We find that women authors were present in AJS from the earliest days, though their share of authorships never was large, and fluctuated year byyear. Women's work was distinctively different from that of men, with more women than men writing empirical, evidence-based articles, focusing on women, children, immigrants, the poor, and other have-not groups, and advocating for social reform. Writings of rank-and-file and prominent women sociologists were similar in methods, content, and form, and their distinctive contributions to sociology paralleled many of the concerns of feminist sociologists today.

“An Earnest Desire for the Truth despite Its Possible Unpleasantness”: A Comparative Analysis of the Atlanta University Publications and American Journal of Sociology, 1895 to 1917

“…When a methodology was presented, according to Rouse, it was less rigorous than the accepted conventions of the day. Linda Grant, Marybeth C. Stalp, and Kathryn B. Ward (2002) contributed to this literature by offering a comparative analysis of the writings of female contributors against their male counterparts prior to World War II.…”

Urban Ethnography's “Saloon Problem” and Its Challenge to Public Sociology

“…These neighborhood institutions were organized in reaction to popular fears over the swelling ranks of the immigrant poor. Integral to American sociology before World War I, they occupied a “separate sphere” headed by Jane Addams, the nominal head of Chicago's Hull House (Deegan, 1988; Grant, Stalp et al, 2002; Lengermann and Niebrugge–Brantly, 2002; Sibley, 1995). As she proudly noted, “the settlements antedated by three years the first sociology departments in universities and by ten years the establishment of the first foundations for social research” (Addams, 1930).…”

Classical Sociology Through the Lens of Gendered Experiences

“…They described each woman's contribution to sociology and also some differences among these female sociologists and male sociologists concerning their choice of aspects to be observed . In their study, Grant et al ( 2002 ) explored sociological writings by women and men between 1895 and 1940. They argued that women's work was different to that of men.…”