Working for patient safety: a qualitative study of women’s help-seeking during acute perinatal events

Abstract

BackgroundWomen and their relatives can play an important role in early detection and help seeking for acute perinatal events. Recent UK reports indicate that patient-professional partnership in ‘working for safety’ can be difficult to achieve in practice, sometimes with catastrophic consequences. This research explored the experiences of women and relatives who had experienced early warning signs about their condition and sought help in escalating care.MethodsSecondary analysis of case study data which included qualitative interviews with 22 women purposively sampled on account of experiencing a step up in care and 4 of their relatives from two NHS Trusts in England during 2010. Analysis focused on the type of safety work participants engaged in, and the opportunities and challenges reported by women and family members when negotiating safety at home and in hospital.ResultsWomen and relatives took on a dual responsibility for self-diagnosis, self-care and seeking triage, whilst trying to avoid overburdening stretched services. Being informed, however, did not necessarily enable engagement from staff and services. The women’s narratives highlighted the work that they engaged in to build a case for clinical attention, the negotiations that took place with health care professionals and the strategies women and partners drew on (such as objective signs and symptoms, use of verbal insistence and repetition) to secure clinical help. For some women, the events left them with a lasting feeling that their concerns had been disregarded. Some described a sense of betrayal and loss of trust in an institution they believed had failed to care for them.ConclusionThe notion of ‘safety partnerships’ which suggests a sense of equality and reciprocity was not borne out by our data, especially with regards to the experiences of teenage women. To enable women and families to secure a rapid response in clinical emergencies, strategies need to move beyond the provision of patient information about warning signs. Effective partnerships for safety may be supported by system level change such as improved triage, continuity of care, self-referral pathways and staff training to address asymmetries of power that persist within the health system.

Experiencias de mujeres sobrevivientes a morbilidad materna extrema en México, un estudio cualitativo desde el modelo de las tres demoras

“…El soporte social que narraron respecto a sus redes más cercanas, hace evidente que es necesario fortalecerlas, toda vez que prevalece no sólo una ausencia de conocimiento de las señales de alarma, sino también una falta de sensibilización para brindar un apoyo emocional y práctico real, lo cual resulta relevante, dado que es contrario a lo que otros estudios han referido al respecto, y que aseveran la existencia de redes de apoyo altamente funcionales 25 .…”

Employing the arts for knowledge production and translation: Visualizing new possibilities for women speaking up about safety concerns in maternity

“…Findings from this research demonstrated how women often relied on family members to ensure their safety. The nature of women's safety concern, how it was expressed, existing relationships with staff, their previous experiences of health services, and language influenced women's ability to contribute to escalation of care …”

“…The nature of women's safety concern, how it was expressed, existing relationships with staff, their previous experiences of health services, and language influenced women's ability to contribute to escalation of care. 26 Funding for the Re-Assure project was received for 6 months (July 2016-January 2017) as part of the Cultural Institute at King's Arts, Health and Wellbeing scheme. The scheme brought together health academics at King's and artists with experience of working in the health-care sector to brainstorm arts-based solutions to health-care problems.…”

Exploring the potential for introducing home monitoring of blood pressure during pregnancy into maternity care: current views and experiences of staff—a qualitative study

“…Pilot work in the UK suggests, with support from midwives and doctors, it is feasible and acceptable for women to monitor their BP and urine safely, potentially identifying hypertension earlier and controlling BP better. [8][9][10] SMBP during pregnancy is becoming common in some settings. A Canadian pilot study found Open access more than 60% of women diagnosed with non-proteinuric hypertension in pregnancy were already undertaking SMBP.…”