‘Would it sell more pork?’ Pig farmers’ perceptions of Real Welfare, the welfare outcome component of their farm assurance scheme

Abstract

In the UK, the pig industry is leading the way in the adoption of welfare outcome measures as part of their farm assurance scheme. The welfare outcome assessment (WOA), known as Real Welfare, is conducted by the farmers’ own veterinary surgeon. For the first time, this has allowed the pig industry to evaluate welfare by directly assessing the animal itself and to document the welfare of the UK pig industry as a whole. Farmer perspectives of the addition of a welfare outcome assessment to their farm assurance scheme have yet to be explored. Here, we investigate how the introduction of the Real Welfare protocol has been perceived by the farmers involved, what value it has (if any), whether any practical changes on farm have been a direct consequence of Real Welfare and ultimately whether they consider that the welfare of their pigs has been improved by the introduction of the Real Welfare protocol. Semi-structured interviews with 15 English pig farmers were conducted to explore their perceptions and experiences of the Real Welfare process. Our findings fall into three key areas: the lived experience of Real Welfare, on-farm changes resulting from Real Welfare and suggested improvements to the Real Welfare process as it currently stands. In all the three areas, the value farmers placed on the addition of WOA appeared to reflect their veterinary surgeon’s attitude towards the Real Welfare protocol. If the vet was engaged in the process and actively included the farmer, for example through discussion of their findings, the farmers interviewed had a greater appreciation of the benefits of Real Welfare themselves. It is recommended that future similar schemes should work with veterinary surgeons to ensure their understanding and engagement with the process, as well as identifying and promoting how the scheme will practically benefit individual farmers rather than assuming that they will be motivated to engage for the good of the industry alone. Retailers should be encouraged to use Real Welfare as a marketing tool for pig products to enhance the perceived commercial value of this protocol to farmers.

Study of the Feasibility of Proposed Measures to Assess Animal Welfare for Zebu Beef Farms within Pasture-Based Systems under Tropical Conditions

“…In the United Kingdom and Germany, the beef industry is at the forefront in adopting welfare outcome measures as part of its farm assurance scheme [28,29]. The Colombian Federation of Cattle Breeders-FEDEGAN-proposed the evaluation protocol under validation in this study.…”

Enabling Behaviour Change in Laying Hen Farmers Using Motivational Interviewing

“…Bard and others [11] found that dairy farmers were more inspired to enact change on their farms if their veterinarian had an empathetic and encouraging approach. Similarly, during a welfare assessment scheme for pigs, the 15 farmers interviewed were more positive towards the 'Real Welfare' protocol when the vet was engaging and shared a two-way relationship [12].…”

Cognición en cerdos

“…[2][3][4][5][6][7][8] A pesar de ello, el uso que se le ha dado a este conocimiento poco ha impactado el aprovechamiento de su carne, el mejoramiento de sus condiciones de vida, y su uso como modelo animal para el estudio de trastornos y enfermedades comunes el humano. [9][10][11] Identificar las características sensoriales y cognitivas del cerdo puede ayudarnos a diseñar adecuados programas de manejo reproductivo y de salud, que además de ser eficientes, sean amables con las necesidades biológicas del animal en cuestión. Por otro lado, incrementar nuestro conocimiento sobre la cognición del cerdo puede mejorar su aprovechamiento como modelo animal en el estudio de enfermedades como el Parkinson, el Alzhéimer y la depresión, entre otros.…”