XKMS-Based Key Management for Open LBS in Web Services Environment

XML security – A comparative literature review

“…Due to their similarity XACML and SAML often occur together, particularly in connection with Web Services. Based on XML Security, a lot of these articles focus on establishing an integrated security system for Web Services, with SAML for Single Sign-On and XACML for access control (Lee, Upadhyaya, Rao & Sharman 2005, Zhang, Wang & Zhou 2004, Park, Moon, Jang & Sohn 2004c, Park, Moon, Jang & Sohn 2004b, Park, Kim, Chung, Kim & Won 2005.…”

“…Despite these problems (Park, Kim, Chung, Kim & Won 2005) develops a key management system based on XKMS and Web Services. Trust is established by a one-time activity per session (Single-Sign On) or by evaluating dynamically on every request.…”

“…Both articles tackle the "Signcryption mecha-nisms", a combination of XML Signature and Encryption already discussed in chapter 4.1. For this purpose the architecture was taken from (Park, Kim, Chung, Kim & Won 2005). An implementation of this mechanism with JCE (Java Crypto Extension) and SAX supplies better performance compared to the traditional method while integrity and confidentiality are still preserved.…”

“…Article WS Pub App Enh XSig XEnc XKMS (Alvaro, Farrell, Lindberg, Lockhart & Zhang 2005) 0 E N N 0 0 2 (Barhoom & Zhang 2004) 0 U Y N 2 0 0 (Beznozov, Flinn, Kawamoto & Hartman 2005) 2 E+U N N 1 1 0 (Boyer 2003) 0 E N N 2 0 0 (Bull, Stanski & Squire 2003) 0 U N Y 2 0 0 0 U N Y 2 0 0 (Bull, Squire & Zheng 2004) 0 U N Y 2 0 0 (Camenisch, Gross & Sommer 2006) 2 E Y N 2 0 0 (Chang & Hwang 2007) 0 U N Y 1 2 0 (Chen et al 2005) 2 U Y N 2 0 0 (Cho 2006) 2 U Y N 2 0 0 (Delgado et al 2001) 0 U Y N 1 0 0 (Geuer-Pollmann 2002) 0 U N Y 0 2 0 (Giereth 2005) 0 U Y N 1 2 0 (Hormann et al 2006) 0 E N N 0 0 2 (Hung et al 2003) 2 U Y N 2 2 0 (Hussain & Soh 2004) 0 U N Y 2 0 0 (Hwang & Chang 2004) 0 U N Y 2 2 0 (Imamura et al 2002) 0 E Y N 0 2 0 1 U N Y 1 1 2 (Kim, Kim, Kim & Shim 2006) 1 U N Y 2 0 1 (Kubbilun et al 2005) 0 E+U N Y 2 0 0 (Lee et al 2002) 0 E N Y 2 0 0 (Lee, Kwon, Lee, Oh & Ko 2003) 2 E Y N 1 1 1 (Lee et al 2005 (Park, Moon & Sohn 2003) 0 U Y N 1 1 2 (Park, Moon, Jang & Sohn 2004a) 2 U N Y 1 1 2 (Park, Moon, Jang & Sohn 2004b) 2 U Y N 1 1 2 (Park, Moon, Jang & Sohn 2004c) 2 U Y N 1 1 2 2 E N Y 1 1 2 1 U Y N 1 1 2 (Park, Kim, Chung, Kim & Won 2005) 2 U Y N 1 1 2 (Park, Moon, Jang, Sohn & Won 2005) 2 U N Y 1 1 2 (Park, Moon, Kim, Chung & Sohn 2005) 2 Y Y Y 2 0 0 (Park et al 2006) 1 U Y Y 2 2 2 (Polivy & Tamassia 2002) 2 E+U Y N 2 0 0 (Schadow 2005) 0 Priv. Y N 2 2 0 (Shirasuna et al 2004) 1 U N N 2 0 0 (Sun ...…”