Conjugates of the anti-CanAg humanized monoclonal antibody huC242 with the microtubule-formation inhibitor DM1 (a maytansinoid), or with the DNA alkylator DC1 (a CC1065 analogue), have been evaluated for their ability to eradicate mixed cell populations formed from CanAg-positive and CanAg-negative cells in culture and in xenograft tumors in mice. We found that in culture, conjugates of either drug killed not only the target antigen-positive cells but also the neighboring antigen-negative cells. Furthermore, we showed that, in vivo, these conjugates were effective in eradicating tumors containing both antigen-positive and antigen-negative cells. The presence of antigen-positive cells was required for this killing of bystander cells. This target cell-activated killing of bystander cells was dependent on the nature of the linker between the antibody and the drug. Conjugates linked via a reducible disulfide bond were capable of exerting the bystander effect whereas equally potent conjugates linked via a nonreducible thioether bond were not. Our data offer a rationale for developing optimally constructed antibody-drug conjugates for treating tumors that express the target antigen either in a homogeneous or heterogeneous manner. (Cancer Res 2006; 66(6): 3214-21)

Maytansine, a highly cytotoxic natural product, failed as an anticancer agent in human clinical trials because of unacceptable systemic toxicity. The potent cell killing ability of maytansine can be used in a targeted delivery approach for the selective destruction of cancer cells. A series of new maytansinoids, bearing a disulfide or thiol substituent were synthesized. The chain length of the ester side chain and the degree of steric hindrance on the carbon atom bearing the thiol substituent were varied. Several of these maytansinoids were found to be even more potent in vitro than maytansine. The targeted delivery of these maytansinoids, using monoclonal antibodies, resulted in a high, specific killing of the targeted cells in vitro and remarkable antitumor activity in vivo.

In this report, we describe the synthesis of a panel of disulfide-linked huC242 (anti-CanAg) antibody maytansinoid conjugates (AMCs), which have varying levels of steric hindrance around the disulfide bond, in order to investigate the relationship between stability to reduction of the disulfide linker and antitumor activity of the conjugate in vivo. The conjugates were first tested for stability to reduction by dithiothreitol in vitro and for plasma stability in CD1 mice. It was found that the conjugates having the more sterically hindered disulfide linkages were more stable to reductive cleavage of the maytansinoid in both settings. When the panel of conjugates was tested for in vivo efficacy in two human colon cancer xenograft models in SCID mice, it was found that the conjugate with intermediate disulfide bond stability having two methyl groups on the maytansinoid side of the disulfide bond and no methyl groups on the linker side of the disulfide bond (huC242-SPDB-DM4) displayed the best efficacy. The ranking of in vivo efficacies of the conjugates was not predicted by their in vitro potencies, since all conjugates were highly active in vitro, including a huC242-SMCC-DM1 conjugate with a noncleavable linkage which showed only marginal activity in vivo. These data suggest that factors in addition to intrinsic conjugate potency and conjugate half-life in plasma influence the magnitude of antitumor activity observed for an AMC in vivo. We provide evidence that bystander killing of neighboring nontargeted tumor cells by diffusible cytotoxic metabolites produced from target cell processing of disulfide-linked antibody-maytansinoid conjugates may be one additional factor contributing to the activity of these conjugates in vivo.

Taxoids bearing methyldisulfanyl(alkanoyl) groups for taxoid-antibody immunoconjugates were designed, synthesized and their activities evaluated. A highly cytotoxic C-10 methyldisulfanylpropanoyl taxoid was conjugated to monoclonal antibodies recognizing the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) expressed in human squamous cancers. These conjugates were shown to possess remarkable target-specific antitumor activity in vivo against EGFR-expressing A431 tumor xenografts in severe combined immune deficiency mice, resulting in complete inhibition of tumor growth in all the treated mice.