“…Imagine then, my surprise and that of my students upon reading the recent communication by Mascal and co-workers disclosing the preparation of "extraordinary" oxonium ions (Figure 1), namely tricyclic oxatriquinane 1, oxatriquinene 2, and oxatriquinacene 3. [3,4] New oxonium ions are reported on a somewhat regular basis, though admittedly half-cage compounds such as 1-3, as well as cage compounds like oxaadamantane 4 recently reported by Olah et al, [5] are quite rare. In fact, the only previously well-characterized bicyclic or tricyclic oxonium ion is 5, described by Klages and Jung in 1965.…”