The photocurrent generation in dilute donor organic solar cells (DDOSCs) based on fullerene and non-fullerene acceptors is compared. The donor concentration is kept under 5 wt % to avoid the formation of a percolation pathway for hole transport, as verified by studying the hole mobilities in an insulating polymer matrix. The short-circuit current densities (J sc ) in DDOSCs for three common acceptors are quantified in terms of charge generation, transport, and collection, which are probed using ideal J sc calculated from the transfer matrix method, hole mobility measured from space charge limited current method, and charge collection efficiency, respectively. Using non-fullerene acceptors improves both charge generation and transport, with charge transport being more important in determining J sc in DDOSCs.