“…It is generally thought that Chl Z is oxidized via Car (4,6,7,23,25,26,38,39), based on the observations that Car + is trapped to a larger extent than Chl Z at lower temperatures (21,23,26) and the trapped Car + is mostly replaced with Chl Z + by warming up the sample (23,25,38,39). This electron-transfer pathway (P680 + r Car r Chl Z ) is consistent with the relative positions of these pigments on the D2 side in the X-ray structure of all three groups (10)(11)(12)(13)30) and on the D1 side in the new structure of T. elongatus by Loll et al (13); the Car molecules are positioned between P680 and Chl Z . This pathway, however, was inconvenient for the oxidation of Chl Z (D1) in the context of the X-ray structure of T. Vulcanus (30) and the previous structures of T. elongatus (10,11), in which no Car was found on the D1 side.…”