The R-(+)-enantiomeric form of Dianin's compound and the S-(+)-enantiomeric form of its direct thiachroman analogue both obtained chromatographically employing a cellulose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) column, are shown to undergo supramolecular assembly to form a polar clathrate lattice which is stable even in the absence of a consolidating guest component.Crystal engineering is a major theme of current chemical research 1 . In particular the design of clathrates, in a classical sense cage-type multimolecular crystalline inclusion compounds, has not only inherent scientific interest but is also important for the supramolecular assembly of new systems with applications in, for example, drug delivery, isomer separation, optical resolutions, storage of toxic and reactive materials and second harmonic generation. It has now been firmly established that judicious modification of an appropriate host molecule, based on a knowledge of the crystal structure of the parent host lattice, can lead to new inclusion compounds 2 of both the channel 3 and true closed-cage clathrate 4,5 types.
Scheme 1 Dianin's compound and structural variantsThe present work is concerned with crystal engineering related to Dianin's compound 1a, (Scheme 1), the remarkable inclusion properties of which were first reported in 1914 by A.P.Dianin 6 , a student and biographer of the chemist and composer Alexander Borodin. The parent host 1a, which does not possess an enforced intramolecular cavity, is particularly attractive from the viewpoint of carefully chosen structural modification. It offers multiple points of substitution, variation of the two functional groups and of crucial importance to the present work is chiral and can be resolved into its two enantiomers 7 . At the end of the 1960's it was established that both compound 1a 8 and its thia analogue 4-p-hydroxyphenyl-2,2,4-trimethylthiachroman, (ThiaDianin's compound), 2 9,10 , (Scheme 1), form isomorphous and isostructural clathrates in the centrosymmetric space group R 3 , with the two host lattices being stable even in the absence of a guest. Further packing modes involving 1a, demonstrating the breakdown of the isomorphous and isostructural behaviour of Dianin's compound along with computational stability studies on the host lattice have also been studied 11 . In a recent paper Jacobs et al. presented a quasiracemic organic host prepared from the cocrystallisation of the resolved enantiomers of Dianin's compound 1a and its mercapto analogue 1b 13 . Cocrystallisation of (R)-1a and (S)-1b from CCl 4 produced a CCl 4 clathrate structure in the polar and chiral space group R3 featuring an [SH … OH] 3 hexamer replacing the [OH] 6 and [SH] 6 hexamers of racemic 1a and 1b respectively. The reduction in symmetry from R 3 to R3 allowed for the polar ordering of the CCl 4 guest molecules, (two per cage), such that a preferential alignment of the C-Cl bonds along the polar axis toward the host phenolic moiety was achieved in the ratio of 85 : 15. Desolvation of this material however resulted ...