“…Widely recognised covariates of AOEs such as dependence severity (Connor, Gudgeon, Young, & Saunders, 2007), age (Monk & Heim, 2013;Mooney, Fromme, Kivlahan, & Marlatt, 1987), and gender (Mooney et al, 1987;Read, Wood, Lejuez, Palfai, & Slack, 2004) were not controlled within any of the studies, with the exception of Jones and McMahon (1996). Drinking behaviours were either not reported (Brown et al, 1998), or collapsed within less sensitive categorical variables (Connors et al, 1993;Jones & McMahon, 1996;R McD Young et al, 2011). As the intention of all treatments was to help patients abstain from alcohol, the relationship between drinking behaviour and AOE change is important to the interpretation of results.…”