A 5-year Overview of Forearm Fracture Etiology and Treatment Options in 7-15 Years Old Children

Abstract

SummaryIntroduction.Forearm fractures make up a significant part of overall fracture rate in pediatric population, especially in 7-15 years old children. Different methods of treatment have been used, depending on the age of children and type and localization of fracture. Most controversies can be seen among conservative and surgical methods of treatment.Aim of the Study.The aim of our study is to identify common localizations and types of forearm bone fractures in pediatric population, as well as analyze patient data and treatment process depending on selected method of treatment for out-patients and in-patients.Materials and Methods.Retrospective analysis of out-patient and in-patient records, treated in University Children’s hospital from 2007 to 2011 was made, including first time patients with fractures of one or both forearm bones, according to ICD-10 codes S52.0- S52.9. Demographical data, trauma mechanisms, localization and type of fracture, as well as applied treatment and stay length at hospital were analyzed. 1742 out-patients and 1029 in-patients, 7-15 years old at the moment of trauma, were included in this research.Results.2771 forearm fractures were registered, 62.9% patients were treated on out-patient basis, 37.1 % patients required treatment in hospital. Forearm bone fractures were gender specific - 2235 boys and 536 girls had to be treated (Male:Female ratio was 4.2 : 1). The peak incidence was seen in 13 years old boys and girls. Boys suffered from forearm fractures more often in any age group. Most common mechanisms of injuries causing forearm fractures in children were related with sports trainings - 22.1%, skiing - 15.0% and traffic injuries - 10.0%. Most common activities at the moment of trauma differ by season - during winter months they include skiing, skating and sledging while in summer falls from height, bicycles and swings are dominant. Several trauma mechanisms, like sport trainings, are not season-dependent. Some injury mechanisms differ significantly by gender. Boys were more often as girls injured during sports trainings and skiing, while girls experience forearm fractures due to bicycling and skating. Occurrence of forearm fractures in children has seasonal differences with two peaks: from June to August and from December to February. Distal forearm fractures are the most often seen localization of overall forearm fractures (42 % in boys and 36 % in girls). In out-patients group conservative treatment was performed - plaster immobilization in 1339 cases and closed reduction, followed by plaster immobilization in 403 cases. In-patients were treated both - conservatively with immobilization in 21 cases and closed reduction in 188 cases, and surgically with K-wire osteosynthesis in 137 cases or elastic stable intramedullary nailing (ESIN) in 683 cases. The type and localization of each fracture, along with the age of patient, are the key factors for choosing the right treatment method. K-wire osteosynthesis was performed in all age groups for unstable fractures in distal or proximal third of forearm. ESIN was a method of choice for unstable or comminuted midshaft fractures of one or both bones, metadiaphyseal fractures and some specific conditions (radial neck fractures, Monteggia fractures-dislocations), especially in older patients. Stay length at hospital was ranging from 1 to 2 hospital days in case of immobilization (mean = 1,05 days), from 1 to 4 days in closed reduction group (mean = 1,32 days), but 1 to 12 days in hospital spent children after K-wire osteosynthesis (mean = 1,99 days) or ESIN (mean = 2,38 days).Conclusions.1. Forearm fractures in children have a significant gender diversity (M : F ratio is 4,2 : 1).2. Peak incidence group is 13 years old adolescents of both genders.3. Seasonality and season-specific injury patterns are typical for pediatric forearm fractures.4. The most common anatomic localization is the distal segment of forearm bones.5. Younger children (7-9 years) are mainly treated by conservative methods, while methods of choice for treatment of forearm fractures in adolescents (13-15 years) are operative.6. Surgical treatment of fractures do not significantly increase stay length at hospital.

Goniometric Estimation of Treatment Efficiency in Pediatric Midshaft Forearm Fracture Patients

“…We could not establish statistically significant correlation, proving that limitations are found more often in younger or older children, but what we found is the difference of treatment efficiency in favor of surgical approach. We have used to consider that surgery is used more for older children, while younger children usually undergo conservative treatment, they have faster healing and thus -better functional outcome [29,33,37]. Our results with patient randomization showed that there are no differences among age groups treated by the same method.…”

“…Analyzing influence of the dominating hand, we found that it was injured more often (1.14:1). This is an interesting finding, because usually dominant hand is considered to be "stronger", as it is more used, has increased muscle mass and better tolerance to similar impact (11,33). Despite the wide use of goniometry in physical therapy for objective assessment or ROM, the reliability of using it under clinical settings is variable, and depends significantly on experience of tester and performance of the assessment (intratester errors), number or persons performing the same study (intratester errors), and tool used (intertool errors) (15,17,27).…”