A Bottom-Up Understanding of Illegal, Unreported, and Unregulated Fishing in Lake Victoria

Abstract

Illegal, unreported, and unregulated (IUU) fishing is a major concern in fisheries management around the world. Several measures have been taken to address the problem. In Lake Victoria, the alleviation of IUU fishing is implemented through the Regional Plan of Action (RPOA-IUU), which restricts use of certain fishing gear, as well as prohibits fishing in closed areas and during closed seasons. Despite the long-term efforts to monitor and control what goes on in the fisheries, IUU fishing has persisted in Lake Victoria. Inspired by interactive governance theory, this paper argues that the persistence of IUU fishing could be due to different images that stakeholders have about the situation, rather than the lack of management competency. Through structured interviews with 150 fisheries stakeholders on Ijinga Island in the southeastern part of Lake Victoria, Tanzania, using paired comparison questionnaires, the study elicits stakeholders' perspective about the severity of different locally-pertinent fishing-related activities. The results show that while fisheries stakeholder groups agree on their judgments about certain fishing gears, some differences are also apparent. For instance, fisheries managers and scientists do not always agree with fishing people about what activities cause the most damage to fisheries resources and ecosystem. Further, they tend to consider some IUU fishing-related activities less damaging than some non-IUU fishing. Such disparity creates governability challenges, pointing to the need to revisit relevant regulatory measures and to make them consistent with the knowledge and judgments of all stakeholders. Based on these findings, we discuss governing interventions that may contribute to addressing IUU fishing in Lake Victoria and elsewhere.

Analyses of Protection and Conservation According to the Fish Act 1950 in Bangladesh’s Kaptai Lake Fisheries Management

“…Furthermore, stakeholder involvement in lake management may decrease the incidence of illegal equipment use. Comanagement, particularly in sanctuaries, would make it easier for fishers to participate in fisheries management, potentially lowering costs for fisheries departments and law enforcement [29]. This is expected to significantly raise fishermen's knowledge and motivation to conserve the resources they rely on for a living.…”

Socio-economic Implications of Imported Frozen Tilapia on the Local fish Production and Value Chain Linkages: Case of Kisumu County, Kenya

“…This has become the reason for decline in the fish catch over the past years as reported by fishermen in Usoma and Dunga Beaches of Lake Victoria. Fishing efforts and unsustainable fisheries in Lake Victoria will continue to increase until the open-access fishing system is replaced by proper enforcement of the licensing system (Luomba et al, 2016). Fishermen experience fluctuation in the amount of fish catch at different periods of the year.…”

A framework for co‐developing conservation research projects with stakeholders: A Lake Victoria case study

“…After carefully reviewing the issues and literature, the research team for the present study decided to focus on the declining Nile perch stock in Lake Victoria, since it was the most frequently discussed stakeholder issue, as well as being consistent with the funding call requirements and matching the skills and expertise of the research team. The Nile perch fishery is a significant source of revenue in the Lake Victoria region, but includes high levels of illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing (Luomba et al, 2013, 2016; Onyango et al, 2020). Thus, the research concept focused on the economic incentives, institutional instruments, and stakeholder perceptions that may hinder the sustainable management of the Nile Perch fishery.…”