A brief intervention for weight management in primary care: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

Abstract

BackgroundObesity affects 25% of the UK adult population but modest weight loss can reduce the incidence of obesity-related chronic disease. Some effective weight loss treatments exist but there is no nationally available National Health Service (NHS) treatment service, and general practitioners (GPs) rarely discuss weight management with patients or support behavior change. Evidence shows that commercial weight management services, that most primary care trusts have 'on prescription', are more effective than primary care treatment.Methods/designWe propose a controlled trial where patients will be randomized to receive either the offer of help by referral to a weight management service and follow-up to assess progress, or advice to lose weight on medical grounds. The primary outcome will be weight change at 12-months. Other questions are: what actions do people take to manage their weight in response to the two GP intervention types? How do obese patients feel about GPs opportunistically discussing weight management and how does this vary by intervention type? How do GPs feel about raising the issue opportunistically and giving the two types of brief intervention? What is the cost per kg/m2 lost for each intervention? Research assistants visiting GP practices in England (n = 60) would objectively measure weight and height prior to GP consultations and randomize willing patients (body mass index 30+, excess body fat, 18+ years) using sealed envelopes. Full recruitment (n = 1824) is feasible in 46 weeks, requiring six sessions of advice-giving per GP. Participants will be contacted at 3 months (postintervention) via telephone to identify actions they have taken to manage their weight. We will book appointments for participants to be seen at their GP practice for a 12-month follow-up.DiscussionTrial results could make the case for brief interventions for obese people consulting their GP and introduce widespread simple treatments akin to the NHS Stop Smoking Service. Likewise, the intervention could be introduced in the Quality and Outcomes Framework and influence practice worldwide.Trial registrationCurrent Controlled Trials ISRCTN26563137.

Does Type 2 Diabetes Genetic Testing and Counseling Reduce Modifiable Risk Factors? A Randomized Controlled Trial of Veterans

“…Although intensive lifestyle interventions are the gold standard for weight loss, 31 a single brief intervention can motivate some patients to change their behavior, 32 and reflects the reality of most primary care settings. Therefore, it is important to determine whether brief interventions provided in primary care can be augmented by strategies such as incorporation of genetic counseling and testing.…”

Screening and brief intervention for obesity in primary care: a parallel, two-arm, randomised trial

“…The full trial protocol has been reported previously 15 and is available online. The protocol was implemented without changes.…”

Interventions targeted at primary care practitioners to improve the identification and referral of patients with co-morbid obesity: a realist review protocol

“…Both of these issues are relevant in this review. First, as noted above, we know that two systematic reviews found very few interventions targeted at primary care practitioners to improve the screening and referral of adults with obesity [ 25 , 27 ], though these are now a number of years old, and this is clearly an area where new research is being produced on a regular basis [ 17 , 37 ]. Second, we know from similar research into interventions targeted at primary care practitioners to improve identification and referral in sensitive areas - in this case intimate partner violence screening [ 38 ] - that there are a number of different potential intervention components (for example effective protocols, ongoing training, feedback, improving access to support), which may in turn have different mechanisms underpinning them (for example practitioner self-efficacy, trust and confidence in the service, accepting responsibility).…”

“…This is a time commitment that most GPs and PNs would be unable to make. More recently, attention has turned towards the use of brief interventions for weight management in primary care, building on the successful use of brief interventions for smoking cessation or alcohol [ 17 ]. It remains to be seen how transferrable such an approach might be in the context of weight management, as there are significant qualitative differences between the discussion of a patient’s weight and that of their smoking or alcohol intake, as the following barriers demonstrate.…”