We present a case of plaque rupture located inside a restenotic stent. Intravascular ultrasound defined a lesion with a minimal lumen area (MLA) of 3.59 cm², plaque burden of 72%, and reference vessel luminal diameter of 4.0 mm with an external elastic membrane lumen cross-section area of 12.6 mm². There was a clearly identified plaque rupture, with a flap-like dissection within the stented segment. Virtual histology intravascular ultrasound confirmed that the adjacent plaque had necrotic core with a thin overlying fibrous cap. The remaining tissue next to the dissection plane was fibrotic. This case illustrates that neointimal hyperplasia may organize into an unstable plaque, with a thin fibrous cap overlying a lipid-rich necrotic core-a so-called virtual histology thin-capped fibroatheroma. As defined in the PROSPECT trial, the in-stent stenotic lesion in our case conformed to the definition of a high-risk plaque-it had an MLA < 4 mm², plaque burden was ≥ 70%, and there was >10% necrotic core. It became unstable and ruptured. The demonstrated findings of this case may sway physicians against sealing hemodynamically nonsignificant unstable plaques.