A CDA Perspective of Cultural Contents in the English Junior High School Textbooks

Abstract

In the aim to engage the volatile future, Kemendikbud considered developing the textbooks with cultural values imbued for the 2013 Curriculum. This study is a content analysis that seeks to examine the cultural elements found in the English textbooks for junior high schoolers, to discover the evidence of global cultural manifestation in the textbooks, as well as to find out the space given to local culture in the textbooks. The data were collected from the latest revision of ‘When English Rings a Bell’ textbook for both 7th & 8th grade, and ‘Think Globally Act Locally’ textbook for 9th grade. The data then analyzed qualitatively. The findings showed that: (1) social group & social identity dictate the cultural dimension, followed by belief & behavior. While another aspect, such as stereotypes & national identity, social interaction, the life-cycle & socialization, national culture heritage, national geography, national history as well as socio-political institution, are not commonly presented. This idea is in line with the curriculum objectives to facilitate the development of students with proper character, behavior and a strong sense of nationality. In terms of proportionality as shown by cultural dimensions, it is inferred that the English textbooks are on their way to perfection; (2) the existence of the target cultures is still dominant, yet the authors had tried to maintain the initial content of the source culture, as well as (3) the students require to realize the importance of learning culture from their English textbooks & develop their cultural competence and a certain degree of respect, as well as tolerance for others.

Anti-Corruption Values Potrayal in English Textbooks for Senior High School Grade XII: Critical Discourse Analysis Perspective

“…Thus, a textbook can be analyzed in various ways and one of the typical analyses usually being used is critical discourse analysis. Mandarani et al (2021) explain that critical discourse analysis may help to connect the text and discourse in the cultural and social context in the community where the textbooks are being used. Looking at the previous explanation, Critical discourse analysis is an appropriate research method for analyzing textbooks looking at anti-corruption values being represented in English textbooks for high school grade XII.…”

Multicultural Competence in English Language Pedagogy: An Analysis of Cultural Values in Indonesian Primary ELT Textbooks

“…In spite of having a fair number of multicultural topics, the textbook still underrepresented Asian and African cultural materials. More recently, Mandarani, et al, (2021) investigated three textbooks of junior high school in Indonesia, that: social group & social identity dictate the cultural ideal, and the presence of the that discourse as text is both a process and a product, created, infused, and defined in a particular social connection. CDA in this study was used to verify verbal and visual texts in two textbooks to illustrate the deputation of cultural values.…”

Critical Discourse Analysis of Moral Values in EFL Textbook for Senior High School

“…Widodo (2018) asserts that textbooks carry messages or values not known by teachers and students, described in visual and verbal texts. Mandarani et al (2021) argue that textbooks represent their character values. According to Xiong (2012), moral values are very high-quality educational values because these values are signs of social humanity or civilized culture, such as caring, a sense of responsibility, and concern.…”