A CFD and experimental study on cavitation in positive displacement pumps: Benefits and drawbacks of the ‘full’ cavitation model

Abstract

To fill the gap in the literature in terms of numerical studies of positive displacement (PD) pumps in a cavitating condition, a comprehensive and transient computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model of a PD pump, simulating the cavitation arising during the suction stroke, was created. The 'full' cavitation model was utilized to study its capability on PD pump cavitation. A set of three plunger speeds were simulated. Using the highest plunger speed, an assessment was made of the effect of 1.5, 3, 4.5 and 15 parts per million (ppm) of air mass fraction on pump performance and cavitation. An experimental test rig, replicating the CFD model, was designed and built in order to validate the numerical model and find its weaknesses. CFD modeled, in a consistent way, the fluid dynamics phenomena related to cavitation (the chamber pressure approaching the vapor pressure, the vaporization/condensation and the pressure spike occurrence at the end of the suction stroke marking the end of cavitation). On the other hand the CFD pressure trends calculated appeared stretched along the time axis with respect to the experimental data, and this highlighted issues in the multiphase and cavitation models: the vaporization/condensation rate calculated by CFD did not follow the real dynamics correctly because the non-condensable gas expansion was overestimated. This was seen when comparing the CFD/experimental results where the simulated pressure drop gradient at the beginning of the suction stroke and the pressure peaks as the valve closed exhibited a delay in their occurrence. The simulation results were sensitive to the dissolved air mass fraction as the delay depended on the amount of air dissolved in the water. Although the influence of the air mass fraction was considered consistent, the 3 ppm CFD case was the closest to the experimental results, whereas the analyst expected the 15 ppm case to be more accurate. ARTICLE HISTORY

First attempt to determine the critical inlet pressure for aircraft pumps with a numerical approach that considers vapor cavitation and air aeration

“…As can be seen in equation 12, the variation of the gas fraction over time is mainly affected by two factors: gas mass variation and mixture mass variation, which are represented by the two terms on the left of equation (12). According to the law of conservation of mass, the gas mass variation in the CV can be determined as follows:…”

“…11 Some of the aforementioned models were successfully implemented in commercial computational fluid dynamic solvers. [12][13][14][15] However, these approaches are often highly computationally expensive for simulation in complex fluid domains such as for axial piston machines. The lumped parameter of continuum modeling methods can be used for producing sufficiently accurate results, and a careful study of the overall features of hydraulic machines or components can reduce computational costs.…”

Analysis on the Performance Improvement of Reciprocating Pump with Variable Stiffness Valve using CFD

“…Based on CFD method, this paper mainly studies the movement characteristics of the suction valve and the distribution of the internal flow field during suction stroke. Due to the discharge valve is closed during this process, only the fluid in suction chamber, valve clearance and pump chamber needs to be considered and analyzed (Iannetti et al, 2016). Therefore, the geometric model established of fluid domain is shown in Fig.…”

Numerical methodology for the CFD simulation of diaphragm volumetric pumps

“…In addition, CFD simulations have recently emerged as a powerful tool to analyze in detail the spatial characteristics of the flow patterns within volumetric flow pumps. The performance of plunger pumps as a function of the crank angle [14], the evaluation of its inlet stroke performance [15] and even cavitation inception [16,17] are some examples of the potentiality of computational modelling. The unsteady simulation of airoperated piston pumps [18] and the numerical analysis of axial piston pumps [19,20] are also significant contributions for the study of reciprocating pumps via CFD.…”