“…Second, the distribution of positive findings has been patchy, with only limited replication (in the strict sense of same allele, same phenotype). For example, three recent case-control studies (8,16,18) could not replicate previously reported associations between mt16189 and T2D (10,11), and whereas the C-tract has been associated with thinness in early life (12), the association may be reversed in later life (12,13). Third, many studies have used genotyping methods susceptible to error or liable to miss potentially relevant variation elsewhere in the OriB region (e.g.…”