A Comparative Analysis of Shenzhen and Kashgar in Development as Special Economic Zones

Abstract

Kashgar, a westernmost city in the restive Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region bordering Central and South Asia, was paired with the southern city of Shenzhen, the most successful special economic zone for its future development. The development of Kashgar's economy in specific and the Xinjiang in general is a part of China's new Silk Road project which serves multi-purpose goals, such as narrowing regional disparity, reducing ethnic tensions, fighting terrorism and balancing US pivot to Asia. It is skeptical whether the Shenzhen model can be transplanted into Kashgar. The plan of developing Kashgar's economy and establishing Kashgar special economic zone may be considered a new bottle with old wine. The development programmes in the past several decades did not address the roots of ethnic tension, including suppression of cultural autonomy and unequal distribution of the benefits and social costs of economic growth. Besides that, the success of the Shenzhen special economic zone is an exception, not a rule. It was unsuccessful in the past attempts to transfer the successful experience from Shenzhen to other special economic zones. It is skeptical whether the Shenzhen experience can be transplanted to Kashgar, whose geographical location and investment environment was much inferior.

Leveraging low state capacity for economic development: a case study of Tajik–Afghan cross-border markets

“…A 2008 report by the World Bank summarizes that the success of an SEZ is defined by its 'policy and incentive framework and the way in which it is located, developed, and managed' (FIAS 2008, 48). In practice, challenges to an SEZ's success take a variety of forms, such as inefficient bureaucracies (Farole and Moberg 2014, 7), a lack of legal investment protection (Izotov 2018, 127), or even simmering ethnic conflicts that disincentivize investment and commerce (Chou and Ding 2015). Among these many determinants, a key consideration is its location and, very often, its proximity to existing economic activity.…”

The effect of special economic zones on governance performance and their spillover effects in Chinese provinces

“…China continued the open door policy since the late 1970s to reform its economy. It established five SEZs 4 and 14 coastal development zones (CDAs) from 1980(CDAs) from to 1984 Since 2010, the Kashgar of Xinjiang Province became the sixth SEZ and is expected to be the "new Shenzhen" of China (Chou & Ding, 2015). In 2016, the Chinese government approved the establishment of 11 free trade zones (FTZs), specific types of SEZs where goods are imported and reexported after handling and manufacturing without direct intervention of customs.…”

The Evolution of Private Provision in Urban Drinking Water: New Geographies, Institutional Ambiguity and the Need for Political Economy

“…To understand this, it is important to understand Shenzhen's unique role in China's development plans. Shenzhen was established as a new, experimental city in 1979, and was allowed to operate a market economy under China's open-door policy (Chou and Ding 2015). Until that time, Shenzhen had been a modest market town known by the name Sham Chun Hui, its population of 30,000 tiny in comparison to the neighbouring metropolis of Hong Kong.…”