A Comparative Study of Financial Crises: Fractal Dissection of Investor Rationality

Abstract

Any non-linear dynamic system can be checked for structural properties only at the time of extremes/crises. Hence, in this research article we tried to investigate stock markets for visible patterns or structures in the vicinity of crashes. We used fractal dimension analysis for studying the volatility of prices and presence of noise and patterns in the time series data of NIFTY, SENSEX and gold. We found change in market predictability of the various time series in the surrounding of crash points. There was measurable change in persistence levels around rupture points. It can be concluded that excessive order in stock markets can choke the markets which then witness crashes to relieve this symmetry and resume randomness for normal functioning. We supported the results with behavioural biases and patterns of investors. The repetitive trading psychology, different intensity of emotions of investors towards their gains and losses, and onset of irrationality and fear leads to worsening of any financial crisis. The crashes can have devastating effects on the economy and the investors. We there have tried to find visible patterns that can serve as warning signals of an approaching crisis. This can be of special assistance to the investors, traders and speculators who enjoy playing in the stock market.

Impact of Investor Sentiment on Contemporaneous and Future Equity Returns in Emerging Markets

“…The controversy observed in the results is attributed to the non-linearity inherent in data (Bekiros et al, 2016), measurement method (Huang et al, 2015b), statistical techniques (Balcilar et al, 2018), structural properties of data (Agarwal & Vats, 2021) and difference in market cultures (W. Wang et al, 2021). Nishiyama et al (2011) are the first to notice the existence of non-linearity between two variables.…”

Fractality of Borsa Istanbul during the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…In this sense, fractal features of time series and economic dynamics are said to be linked. Agarwal et al [28] analyzed the magnitude of fluctuations in gold prices and stock indices during crisis periods.…”