A Comparative Study on the Attitudes and uses of Music by Adults with Visual Impairments and those who are Sighted

Abstract

Introduction This study investigated attitudes (intrapersonal, interpersonal, and communal) toward, and uses of, music among people with visual impairments compared with those who are sighted to investigate the potential of music as a means of communication and social expression. Method A total of 137 participants (63 visually impaired, 74 sighted) were recruited from six cities in South Korea. Participants, aged 20 to 39 years, were asked to complete a 30-question survey on music attitudes and use, which was distributed (electronically, by post, by telephone, and in person) between June 2013 and February 2014. Results The response rate was 87%. Attitudes toward music showed that visually impaired participants demonstrated significantly higher (more positive) values than sighted participants on interpersonal and communal survey dimensions ( p < .05). The groups demonstrated similar results regarding intrapersonal attitudes, which received the highest scores of all three categories. Visually impaired participants mainly accessed music from home via portable devices or computers, whereas sighted participants used music most frequently at their homes or in cars. The most significant difference between groups was that music was involved in the majority of leisure time for visually impaired participants, but not for sighted participants. Discussion Higher attitude scores in the intrapersonal category from both groups imply an important role of music, with its emotional and affective aspects, in self-expression. Findings indicated that visually impaired participants utilized music mainly for self-amusement despite perceiving it as an interpersonal and communal tool, most likely due to social restrictions. Implications for practitioners The role of music in the lives of visually impaired individuals could be expanded to provide more group opportunities, hands-on experiences, enjoyable outdoor activities, and psychosocial coping strategies. Group music programs should be considered in order to expand interpersonal and communal experiences for both visually impaired and sighted individuals.

The Meaning of Musicing in the Post-traumatic Growth of Individuals With Adventitious Visual Impairment: Applying the Life History Method by Mandelbaum

“…This finding is consistent with previous studies reporting that musicing, with an aim to improve social relationships, could help individuals with AVI to form positive relationships with others, thereby reducing their sense of isolation and promoting mutual exchange ( Metell, 2015 ). The findings also agreed with a previous study on the function of music for social groups, which reported that music, to individuals with AVI, could make a marked contribution to promoting the exchange among group members and enabling them to acquire a sense of belonging ( Park et al, 2015 ). Thus, music groups should be utilized actively to help individuals with AVI overcome psychosocial problems such as feelings of loss, alienation, and isolation.…”

Finding meaning through musical growth: Life histories of visually impaired musicians

“…Visually impaired people have the same needs as normally sighted people with respect to becoming functional members of society (Tuttle & Tuttle, 2004). Some visually impaired people actively use other senses (especially hearing) to compensate for their lack of vision and can enjoy music to the same extent as the normally sighted (Park, Chong, & Kim, 2015). As an auditory medium, music can play a vital role in the lives of visually impaired people because of its availability and practicality in terms of personal use (Rostohar, 2006).…”

A comparative study of the perception of music emotion between adults with and without visual impairment

“…Visually impaired people can also use music as a tool for social communication as well as a source of personal enjoyment (Robb, 2003; Wolffe, Koenig, Sacks, & Lewis, 2003; Wolffe & Sacks, 1997). Some of them enjoy participating in group music activities, such as choirs, vocal bands, wind ensembles, and karaoke singing (Park, Chong, & Kim, 2015). Music can facilitate social connections, build mastery and competence, and provide solace in adversity (Werner & Smith, 2001).…”