A comparison of bank and credit union growth around the financial crisis

Abstract

PurposeThe purpose of this research is to examine the growth rates of commercial banks and credit unions around the financial crisis and recovery. Credit unions are analyzed as a group and by field of membership. Specifically, this research analyzes the growth rates of assets, deposits, and loans.Design/methodology/approachThis research employs univariate tests of differences to examine the median growth rates for commercial banks and credit unions. Unbalanced pool regressions analyze growth rates during the pre-crisis, crisis, and recovery periods, controlling for size, net charge-offs, and unemployment.FindingsUnivariate test results that control for size show that banks grow at faster rates than credit unions for most of the pre-crisis years. However, medium sized credit unions grow at faster rates for most of the crisis and recovery years. Results of unbalanced pool regressions suggest that, overall, credit unions grow at slower rates than do banks. However, during the crisis and recovery, credit union growth is significantly greater than that of banks, after controlling for net charge-offs, size, and unemployment. Credit union growth varies by field of membership type.Originality/valueAlthough a large volume of research examines commercial bank performance around the financial crisis, only a few papers assess the performance of credit unions. And very few papers compare commercial banks and credit unions. This paper explores how the recent financial crisis influenced the growth of commercial banks and credit unions from 2005 to 2013.

Does financial crisis change the relationship between bank development and economic growth? Evidence from US states

“…Banks, especially those whose regulatory ratings were downgraded during this period, saw a sharp decline in loans to small and medium-sized enterprises [ 9 ]. With the financial crisis affecting the whole economic development, the American public’s trust in banks had decreased, the function of banks to absorb and mobilize savings had been weakened, and a large amount of savings had been deposited in credit cooperatives [ 10 ]. It is generally believed that the banking industry triggered the financial crisis, but there is still a gap in the understanding of the causal relationship between banking and economic growth before and after the crisis.…”

The impact of COVID-19 on UK community finance institutions – Implications for local economic development

“…We do not have sufficient evidence to assess the relative resilience of the community-based lending model in the face of economic downturns, which is a key question in the academic literature (Lu and Swisher, 2020; Coen et al, 2019). The long-term impact of COVID-19 on affordable credit sector and access to credit for financially excluded consumers is still uncertain.…”

“…Credit unions are not only less likely to experience steep declines in lending during crises, but there is also evidence from the US suggesting that credit unions provide additional liquidity when banks are reducing credit supply. Lu and Swisher (2020) found that US credit union lending grew at a faster rate than bank lending during and following the global financial crisis of 2007. A study by Walker (2016), which examined bank and credit union business lending for 2010-14, concluded that credit unions increased their share of business lending following the financial and economic crisis of 2007. Business loans from credit unions increased by 39.2%, while assets increased by 22.7%.…”

Does bank efficiency mediate the effect of intellectual capital on banking profitability in Indonesia?

“…The role of banking in a country is so vital that management must pay attention to banking performance. Banks have become one of the fastest growing industries and the high and optimistic growth rate of banking assets occurs from year to year (Lu and Swisher, 2020). The ability of banks to carry out their role in determining the economy depends on efficient and effective bank management.…”