A comparison of functional brain changes associated with surgical versus behavioral weight loss

Abstract

Objective Few studies have examined brain changes in response to effective weight loss; none have compared different methods of weight-loss intervention. We compared functional brain changes associated with a behavioral weight loss intervention to those associated with bariatric surgery. Methods 15 obese participants were recruited prior to adjustable gastric banding surgery and 16 obese participants were recruited prior to a behavioral diet intervention. Groups were matched for demographics and amount of weight lost. fMRI scans (visual food motivation paradigm while hungry and following a meal) were conducted before, and 12 weeks after surgery/behavioral intervention. Results When compared to bariatric patients in the pre-meal analyses, behavioral dieters showed increased activation to food images in right medial PFC and left precuneus following weight loss. When compared to behavioral dieters, bariatric patients showed increased activation in in bilateral temporal cortex following the weight loss. Conclusions Behavioral dieters showed increased responses to food cues in medial PFC – a region associated with valuation and processing of self-referent information – when compared to bariatric patients. Bariatric patients showed increased responses to food cues in brain regions associated with higher level perception—when compared to behavioral dieters. The method of weight loss determines unique changes in brain function.

IMAGING IN ENDOCRINOLOGY: The use of functional MRI to study the endocrinology of appetite

“…Patients who had undergone bariatric surgery showed increased responses to food cues in brain regions associated with higher-level perception. This is the first evidence in human subjects that the method of weight loss elicits different brain responses, and it may begin to explain why some approaches are more successful than others (70).…”

Extended calorie restriction suppresses overall and specific food cravings: a systematic review and a meta‐analysis

“…Neuroimaging studies conducted for varied purposes that were able to indirectly examine this question indicate that extended calorie restriction may suppress food-cue reactivity of brain regions that regulate food reward 30–32 and are by extension, often thought to be a neurophysiological surrogate for “craving”. Similarly, regions that are often thought to “suppress food cravings” show enhanced food-cue reactivity indicating increased executive inhibitory control over drives towards ingestion 30 (i.e.…”

Neuroendocrine adaptations to bariatric surgery

“…Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) scans of the brain in response to visual food cues are altered in quite different ways following LAGB induced weight loss when compared with intentional dietary weight loss. LAGB patients developed increased responses in brain areas responsible for higher level perception when compared with similar dietary weight loss (Bruce et al, 2014). RYGB patients report reduced sweet and fatty foods intake, that often cause dumping syndrome, while possibly increasing vegetable consumption (Olbers et al, 2006).…”