A Comparison of Functional Features of Chinese and US Mobile Apps for Pregnancy and Postnatal Care: A Systematic App Store Search and Content Analysis

Abstract

BackgroundPregnancy to postpartum (PtP) applications (apps) are becoming more common tools to document everything from pregnancy and delivery to nutrient allocation, life taboos, and infant medical examinations. However, the dependability, quality, and efficacy of these apps remain unclear. This study examined the features and functions of mobile PtP care apps accessible in China and the United States and to identify the major gaps that need to be addressed.MethodsApps were selected by searching the Apple App Store and Android Markets (in the US and China) for the terms “pregnancy” and “postpartum” in Chinese and English. The apps' security, quality, and effectiveness were investigated, and chi-square tests and analysis of variance were performed to examine the differences in characteristics between apps available in the US and China.ResultsA total of 84 mobile PtP care apps (45 from the US and 39 from China) were included. A total of 89.7% (35/39) of Chinese mobile apps did not provide safety statements or supporting evidence. The objective app quality ratings for Chinese and US apps were 3.20 ± 0.48 (mean ± standard deviation) and 3.56 ± 0.45, respectively (p > 0.05). A greater number of Chinese apps provided app-based monitoring functions, namely recording fetal size (n = 18, 46.2% in China vs. n = 3, 6.7% in the US), contractions (n = 11, 28.2% in China vs. n = 0, 0% in the US), pregnancy weight (n = 11, 28.2% in China vs. 0, 0% in the US), and pregnancy check-up reminders (n = 10, 25.6% in China vs. n = 0, 0% in the US). Meanwhile, a greater number of US apps provided exercise modules, namely pregnancy yoga (n = 2, 5.1% in China vs. n = 21, 46.7% in the US), pregnancy workouts (n = 2, 5.1% in China vs. n = 13, 28.9% in the US), and pregnancy meditation (n = 0, 0% in China vs. 10, 22.2% in the US) (p < 0.01). A medium security risk was identified for 40% (18/45) of apps in the US and 82.1% (32/39) of apps in China (p < 0.01).ConclusionsThe functionality and characteristics of in-store mobile apps for PtP care varied between China and the US. Both countries' apps, particularly Chinese apps, encountered issues related to a lack of evidence-based information, acceptable content risk, and program evaluations. Both countries' apps lacked proper mental health care functions. The findings suggest that the design of app features should be enhanced in both countries, and increased interaction between app creators and users is recommended.

Pregnancy Activity Levels and Impediments in the Era of COVID-19 Based on the Health Belief Model: A Cross-Sectional Study

“…For instance, women’s associations and communities could increase publicity, universities could invite expert physicians and coaches to offer relevant courses, and a network platform could be established to minimize equipment expenses and ensure safety in the context of COVID-19. For instance, mobile applications (e.g., apps focused on weight management, mental health, nutrition knowledge, counseling medical personnel, and exercise training online) may be beneficial for improving maternal physical and mental health during the pandemic, and affordability represents a major advantage of mobile apps [ 47 , 48 ]. The government may consider providing special activity venues and facilities for pregnant women when planning various community construction projects.…”

A socio-ecological model of factors influencing physical activity in pregnant women: a systematic review

“…Therefore, overcoming barriers to PA requires a deep integration of PA and medicine. With advancements in technology, mobile applications and digital technologies provide opportunities for real-time interaction, information sharing, and multisectoral collaboration ( 63 ). In this case, governments should join forces with relevant organizations to increase advocacy and knowledge and consolidate resources to create a more supportive environment through a government-led, multisectoral collaborative approach to health interventions.…”

Understanding and Involving the Perspective of Pregnant Women as Users When Designing the Framework of e-Health and Exercise Interventions during Pregnancy: Preliminary Study

“…Paradoxically, pregnancy is the medical condition with the largest number of apps available; however, mobile apps designed specifically to increase physical activity during pregnancy are scarce, and user interaction with these technologies is critical and culturally specific [ 14 ]. Moreover, available apps show low incorporation of behavior change techniques [ 5 ], and those that do focus on such an objective do not follow the current physical activity guidelines [ 15 ]. Another problem with exercise apps designed for pregnancy is that they do not consider current evidence-based physical activity guidelines, prior screening for contraindications to physical activity, adequate personalization resources to take into account the characteristics of the pregnant woman, and the involvement of qualified exercise professionals during app development [ 2 ].…”