A compositional approach for modelling SDG7 indicators: Case study applied to electricity access

Abstract

Monitoring energy indicators has acquired a renewed interest with the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, and specifically with goal 7 (SDG7), which seeks to guarantee universal access to energy. The predominant criteria to monitor SDG7 are given in a set of individual indicators. Along this line, the UN indicators proposed in the 47th session of the UN Statistical commission are a practical starting point. A relevant characteristic of these indicators is that they can be expressed as proportions from a whole, i.e., they are compositions.Notably, directly implementing traditional multivariate models onto indicators that are proportions without an intermediate process can lead to spurious analysis. Here, we aim to assess the application of compositional data analysis (CoDa) to follow up on the temporal trend indicators of the energy sector in the context of SDG7, with a case study for the most affected areas addressing the problem of electricity access. Following CoDa methodology, we first use a log-ratio transformation to bring compositions to real space and then apply three multivariate methods: linear regression, generalized additive models and support vector machine. We also address other characteristic problems of the electricity access indicators, such as data quality, which was treated by considering mod-

Compositional Data Analysis Approach in the Measurement of Social-Spatial Segregation: Towards a Sustainable and Inclusive City

“…Even though the application of standard methods to compositional data yielded interpretable and apparently reasonable results, the application of standard methods in compositional data are, at best, inappropriate [26]. As explained by Aitchison [25], Pawlowsky-Glahn and Egozcue [26], Filzmoser, Hron, and Reimann [60], Marcillo-Delgado, Ortego and Pérez-Foguet [80], Cruz-Sandoval, Ortego and Roca [29], the use of standard statistical methods in compositional data originate problems, such as prediction of values outside the sample space, spurious correlations and sub-compositional incoherence, among others.…”

National Energy Transition Framework toward SDG7 with Legal Reforms and Policy Bundles: The Case of Taiwan and Its Comparison with Japan

“…However, in the present study, the national energy transition, which we approach via a qualitative analysis, is cross-sectional, and a national pathway is necessary to promote sustainable energy comprehensively and efficiently. (6) Marcillo-Delgado et al [23] adopted a quantitative analysis of electricity access, which is one of the SDG7 indicators and is an aspect of stable supply. Based on stable supply achieved through a path with a diverse supply with renewable energy, Korkovelos et al [24] provided electrification modelling to support SDG7.…”

Tree Ecosystem Services, for Everyone? A Compositional Analysis Approach to Assess the Distribution of Urban Trees as an Indicator of Environmental Justice

“…Analysis of compositional data in a raw form using standard statistical tools may lead to spurious correlations and consequently, to wrong conclusions [57][58][59]. Further consequences can be found in Pearson [76], Chayes [77], Aitchison [78,79], Rock [80] and Rollinson [81].…”

“…Thus, using standard statistical methods to analyze compositional data may lead to biased results. To avoid this, data should be transformed into Aitchison's geometry [57][58][59].…”