Aligned nanofibrous scaffolds hold tremendous potential for the engineering of dense connective tissues. These biomimetic micro-patterns direct organized, cell-mediated matrix deposition, and can be tuned to possess nonlinear and anisotropic mechanical properties. For these scaffolds to function in vivo, however, they must either recapitulate the full dynamic mechanical range of the native tissue upon implantation, or must foster cell infiltration and matrix deposition so as to enable construct maturation to meet these criteria. In our recent studies, we noted that cell infiltration into dense aligned structures is limited, but could be expedited via the inclusion of a distinct, rapidly eroding sacrificial component. In the present study, we sought to further the fabrication of dynamic nanofibrous constructs by combining multiple fiber populations, each with distinct mechanical characteristics, into a single composite nanofibrous scaffold. Towards this goal, we developed a novel method for the generation of aligned electrospun composites containing rapidly eroding (PEO), moderately degradable (PLGA and PCL/PLGA), and slowly degrading (PCL) fiber populations. We evaluated the mechanical properties of these composites upon formation and with degradation in a physiologic environment. Further, we employed a hyperelastic constrained mixture model to capture the nonlinear and time-dependent properties of these scaffolds when formed as single-fiber populations or in multi-polymer composites. After validating this model, we demonstrated that by carefully selecting fiber populations with differing mechanical properties, and altering the relative fraction of each, a wide range of mechanical properties (and degradation characteristics) can be achieved. This advance allows for the rational design of nanofibrous scaffolds to match native tissue properties, and will significantly enhance our ability to fabricate replacements for load bearing tissues of the musculoskeletal system.