A Critical Analysis of Research on Reading Teacher Education

Abstract

This article reports findings from an ethnographic study of the literacy practices of a group of 11-to 14-year-old black males who called themselves "the cool kids." The study is framed using theories that view literacy as a social and cultural practice involving multiple sign-and-symbol systems. Two research questions guided the study: How did coolness relate to literacy among "the cool kids," and what symbolic patterns helped to shape these relations? The findings describe how race, gender, and pop culture marked the group's use of language and style and reveal how coolness, as a pop-cultural artifact of black manhood, contributed to the literacy practices of the young men and to the construction of their symbolic selves. These findings contribute to building a theory of black masculine literacies. F or the young men in the "My Brother's Keeper" (MBK) Program, playing with language and style seemed central to literacy practice. Even their body was a tablet that rendered the self textually, allowing powerful forms of composing to be accomplished and shared. Regularly, we observed the young men of MBK-who, by school accounts, were thought to be barely literate in the narrow, print-based sense of the term-operate within multiple symbolic systems to define themselves and shape what they saw as "cool." They made literate decisions, indeed, scribing identity texts in unstable social situations, for example, in the events of dress and speech. The texts that defined these events-and we include here "cool" vernacular and apparel in addition to traditional print and other multimodal semiotic forms (Hull & Nelson, 2005), such as songs, films, etc.-were circulated, shared, and picked up by the young men in sophisticated ways. The texts they produced were also symbolic, offering a narrative of who these young men were and wanted to be.As we sought to locate meaning in their texts, this study took shape around a particular set of literacy practices firmly rooted within black masculine and popcultural models. Although a growing body of literacy research on urban youth has seemed to harden literacy into a performance of race and gender, we have resisted this impulse. Instead, we present the constructs of race (blackness) and gender (masculinity) merely to present a telling case (Mitchell, 1984). What follows is an examination of literacy revealed through the language and style of 11-to 14-year-old black boys.The initial purpose of the study was to examine the critical literacy practices of the young men of MBK. As we became more familiar with the young men, we became more aware of the social ecology of the group. Important to us was understanding how the literacy practices of seven of its members, "the cool kids" (the phrase "the cool kids" is actual language taken from one of the students in the program), had lifted literacy off the page. As two young black men ourselves, the literacy practices of these young men were both unique and familiar. However, we experienced difficulty finding theories of literacy that acknowledged t...

Work-integrated learning within the reading literacy component of foundation phase teacher preparation programmes

“…Expertise to teach reading matters more than curriculum materials, pedagogical approaches and reading programmes (Allington 2002), and it can be developed through experiences, careful deliberation and reflection on practice, usually through supervision by knowledgeable mentors (Cochran-Smith 2000) using evidence-based reading research practices. Authentic apprenticeships that allow teacher candidates to openly discuss their literacy practices through collaborative problem solving are powerful opportunities to enhance learning (Risko et al 2008). Within the construct of teacher training, the concept of critical self-reflection has emerged as a legitimate strategy for improving and transforming one's practice (Dufour 2004 …”

Honouring ESL students' lived experiences in school learning with multiliteracies pedagogy

“…At its inception, multiliteracies was centred on promoting the acceptance of other forms of literacies which include oral (Enciso, 2011;Owodally, 2011), audio (Kirkland & Jackson, 2009), spatial (Pearce, 2008), information literacy (Beck & Fetherston, 2003;Moody, Justice, & Cabell, 2010;van Wyk & Louw, 2008) and visual literacies (Danzak, 2011;Serafini, 2011). This has led to the development of New Literacies Studies (NLS) in schools.…”

Conceptually and Methodologically Vexing Issues in Teacher Knowledge Assessment

“…The first phase focused on an extensive literature review of three lines of research. The first of these three lines of research focused on exemplary teaching of reading and writing in the primary grades (Baumann, Hoffman, Duffy-Hester, & Ro, 2000;Hoffman & Pearson, 2000;Risko et al, 2008;Taylor, Pearson, Clark, & Walpole, 2000). The second line of research focused on measuring reading teacher content and pedagogical knowledge (Asselin, 1997;Bos et al, 2001;Cunningham et al, 2004;McCutchen et al, 2002;Moats & Foorman, 2003;Phelps & Schilling, 2004.)…”