“…Callipterids have been described from the immediate roof shales of a coal bed at only one place, the Brown's Bridge locality, by Fontaine and White (1880), and here they may actually have occurred in a clastic layer at the base of the Lower Washington Limestone (White, 1891). Other plants typical (but not diagnostic) of Permian-age floras have been reported from the Dunkard and older rocks in the Appalachian Basin including Taeniopteris, Plagiozamites, and conifers (Blake and Gillespie, 2011), including one collection from near the base of the Upper Pennsylvanian (McComas, 1988;Wagner and Lyons, 1997). These are reported from various horizons, including the Cassville Shale, above the Waynesburg coal, at the base of the Dunkard Group (Darrah, 1975;Fontaine and White, 1880;White, 1904White, , 1936.…”